Marinated Stuffed Cherry Peppers

READY IN: 336hrs
Recipe by teaganm

I originally found this recipe here on recipezaar from CC. After playing around with it I came up with this variation. Hope you enjoy!

Top Review by brianshrm

Loved this recipe. I've made about 2 qts so far and plan to do another 3 or 4 qts. The pickling in vinegar seems to work well preserving the crunch of the peppers. I agree with the other comment, you should only use the green cherry peppers. The reds, despite being pickled are too soft. Great recipe. Thanks so much.

Ingredients Nutrition


  1. Wash cherry peppers and place whole, stems intact, in 1 gallon jar.
  2. Fill jar with white vinegar.
  3. Let stand at least one week.
  4. I've let them soak as long as 3 weeks.
  5. You may need to add more vinegar to keep the jar full as the peppers soak it in.
  6. The peppers will float, make sure to keep them covered.
  7. After soaking for at least a week, pour out vinegar and rinse peppers in cool water.
  8. Remove stems and seeds.
  9. Expect to lose 3 or 4 peppers during soaking.
  10. Cut provolone to the appropriate size to fill the peppers.
  11. (~1/2" cube) Cut the Proscuitto slices in half.
  12. Wrap the provolone with a 1/2 slice of Proscuitto (or 2 for larger peppers) and stuff into pepper.
  13. Add some Olive Oil to the jar.
  14. Add Onion, Rosemary, 2 or 3 Bay Leaves, Dill Weed, Basil and chopped Garlic to oil.
  15. Place the peppers in the jar and fill the jar with 50% Olive Oil and 50% Canola Oil.
  16. Top off the jar with a sprikle coating of Parmesan cheese.
  17. Let soak a minimum of one week.
  18. I let them soak and store them at room temperature.
  19. You may want to refrigerate for longer shelf life.
  20. (I've had shelf life in excess of one month) ENJOY!

Join the Conversation

  • all
  • reviews
  • tweaks
  • q & a