Total Time
Prep 10 mins
Cook 15 mins

I am a Thousand Island addict, I use it on everything, so eventually it made it's way into a Macaroni Salad. Don't be disturbed by it's pink appearance. =o)

Ingredients Nutrition


  1. Combine first 6 ingredients, in this step include only the egg yolks leaving the whites.
  2. This is your sauce.
  3. Chop the whites of the eggs.
  4. Stir in remaining ingredients.
  5. Cover, chill (I always top this with a sprinkle of paprika).
Most Helpful

I made this salad especially for my mom who loves thousand island dressing. This was easy to make and the taste was interesting. I chilled it for about 3 hours before serving but the leftovers the next day tasted even better. Thanks for posting-hope you like the photo!

* Pamela * August 16, 2004

Can't find creametts in florida, This is the recipe we use all the time, can't wait til it gets cooler outside so i could put my oven on .

uomeTwo August 01, 2010

My Dh loves thousand island dressing, so we had to try. He gave it 5 stars definately. It almost tasted like a store made noodle salad dressing. Was really easy. I'm thinking it might be good with potatoes, too. I'll let you know.

Jules211 May 15, 2006