Amish Macaroni & Cheese

Amish Macaroni & Cheese created by GrandmaIsCooking

This is a great recipe. Easy to make and delicious. I tried it at a party and really enjoyed it. This recipe is so simple I am embarassed to even post it.

Ready In:
1hr 10mins
Serves:
Units:

ingredients

directions

  • Put Cottage Cheese in 9 x 13 cake pan.
  • Add Macaroni.
  • Add Water.
  • Add shredded cheese.
  • Stir together.
  • Place in preheated 300* oven.
  • Take out after 30 minutes and stir.
  • Place back into oven for 30 more minutes (make sure you check it every few minutes after another 20 minutes because you do not want to overbake it or it will dry out).
Submit a Recipe Correction

MY PRIVATE NOTES

Add a Note
Advertisement
Enter The Sweepstakes
Advertisement

RECIPE MADE WITH LOVE BY

@Rev. Colt
Contributor
@Rev. Colt
Contributor
"This is a great recipe. Easy to make and delicious. I tried it at a party and really enjoyed it. This recipe is so simple I am embarassed to even post it."

Join The Conversation

all
reviews
tweaks
q&a
sort by:
  1. catmaniacs
    I am sorry but we did not care for this. Made as directed, read all reviews prior to making. The flavor was good but the texture was somewhat grainy or off somehow we think it is because you don't cook the macaroni first. We ate our servings but threw the rest, about a half a pan, out. Sorry.
  2. kristinday
    I've made this about a thousand times now, lol! I have finally perfected it. The first few times it was a little dry, however, I figured out exactly when to pull it out, how important it was to stir, etc... I also use 4% cottage cheese to give it that extra moistness. I sometimes add diced ham now, and make it a meal!
  3. The Pixelated Veget
    I had no problem at all with this being dry - but I cooked it covered and it turned out perfectly. I'll add a little bit of spice next time, but otherwise, no adjustments needed. :)
  4. excentrika
    Thanks for posting, because I never would have figured out how to make this! Very simple, in both preparation and taste. It's very good though. My macaroni is a bit chewey, some are even straight up crunch still, but that's okay. Pretty low fat and low cal for mac and cheese. Be sure to stir it like you mean it! Thanks for sharing!
  5. Brookefi
    Not dry at all. I used 24oz of 4% cottage cheese and added 1t onion powder, dry mustard & white pepper. Next time I will use a little less shredded cheese.
Advertisement

Find More Recipes