Hickory Smoked New York Steaks

"Grilled steaks with a distinct Southwest flair. This was a free recipe offered by my local grocery store."
photo by teresas photo by teresas
photo by teresas
Ready In:




  • Combine chili powder, sugar and garlic in a bowl. Add olive oil and combine to paste-like consistency. Rub chili powder mixture into both sides of each steak.
  • Heat one side of the grill and add hickory chips (or wood of your preference). When coals are hot, place steaks on grill so they are away from fire and not directly over heat. Grill for 8 minutes, turning once.
  • Place hickory chips to the side (or remove, if possible). Or heat other side of grill, omitting hickory chips.
  • Finish by grilling steaks for another 4 minutes each side (or to desired doneness) directly over flame, without hickory chips.

Questions & Replies

Got a question? Share it with the community!


  1. Found some fairly large steaks at the supermarket, and was told by the butcher they were a little larger than average, so I increased the rub by 1/3. I made these as posted, except in step 4, I had hickory chips one one side of the grill, and charcoal on the other side. It worked perfectly as these steaks were on top of this world. Loved the hickory flavor, and the rub was very satisfying. Nice quick delicious dinner this was . Well worth the 5 stars. Made for PRMR tag..
  2. I had very small steaks for DH and I. I used eye of round. I let the paste sit on the steaks at room temperature for about half an hour. These cooked up real quick but I did have the chips heating and smoking up the grill prior to putting them on. The hickory flavor was dominate in the overall taste which surprised us both. We love it! This is so easy to whip together and the flavor is just so darn yummy! Thanks for posting.:)


This site used to be awesome. It was at the top of its game when it was called Recipezaar, but that was many years ago. The site was purchased by Scripps and belly-flopped into mediocrity. A few of the faithful members remained, hoping to wait out the storm of corporate nonsense. But alas, it never got better and just continued on its terminal path to nothingness. So most of the loyal members have vanished and made homes at better recipe sites.
View Full Profile

Find More Recipes