Fantasy Pumpkin Fudge

"Wonderful fudge adapted from Kraft Foods. We make this every year for Christmas and Thanksgiving. I had no problem here but since i got such a bad review from jesse wilson i have gone back and used my my penn. Dutch Grama's recipe, so the one you read is not that one that she reviewed."
 
Download
photo by meghanmariemiller1379 photo by meghanmariemiller1379
photo by meghanmariemiller1379
Ready In:
2hrs 20mins
Ingredients:
9
Yields:
PAN
Serves:
10

ingredients

Advertisement

directions

  • Mix first 6 ingredients and bring to boil to soft ball stage, about 240°F (about 12 min.).
  • Remove from heat and add remaining ingredients.
  • Pour into lightly greased 9 inch pan.
  • Chill 2 hours.
  • Cut into squares.

Questions & Replies

Got a question? Share it with the community!
Advertisement

Reviews

  1. This fudge is so delicious! I add a little extra pumpkin pie spice for my own preferences, but it's good without it. It takes a lot longer to cook this fudge than other versions of fantasy fudge (I assume because of the added liquid from the pumpkin) but with some patience, it turns out great. I keep it on the heat until it reaches 234 and then add the chocolate chips and marshmallow just like the original fantasy fudge recipes and I've never had a problem with how it turns out. I have not tried adding the ingredients all at one as this recipe suggests because I was afraid it would alter the final setting stage. If you follow the instructions from original fantasy fudge, everything should turn out perfect with the listed ingredients.
     
    • Review photo by meghanmariemiller1379
  2. I’ve been making fudge forever around the holidays. I make tons of it to put in Christmas and Holiday baskets for gifts to friends. The only time I’ve had a recipe fail was yesterday with this one. It refuses to set up at all. It’s a soft sticky mess that remains too soft to cut properly. I use a candy thermometer so I know it reached proper temp. It also tastes only of nutmeg even though I used my regular pumpkin pie spice I use to make pies and pumpkin bread. I’m guessing because there’s only 1/2 a cup of actual pumpkin in it. I really had high hopes for this one because it’s a pumpkin version of the fantasy fudge recipe. Definitely not making this one again.
     
  3. This smelled amazing, gorgeous color, pefect taste, but would not harden. I followed the recipe to the letter, still came out like soup. UPDATE: I added the extra white chips and YUMMY RESULTS!!!! The fudge set up perfectly. Very little time, huge mess but thats what DH is for right? Thanks for the tip!
     
Advertisement

RECIPE SUBMITTED BY

Gibson family,4 children,from Philadelphia.
 
View Full Profile
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Find More Recipes