Beef Stroganoff

"This is my variation of a recipe given to me about 40 years ago by Elton B. Cornwall, owner of Elton's Restaurant, Upland CA."
 
Download
photo by a food.com user photo by a food.com user
Ready In:
50mins
Ingredients:
13
Serves:

ingredients

Advertisement

directions

  • In large skillet, cook mushrooms, onion, garlic, salt and pepper in 1/4 cup butter over medium heat until just done.
  • Remove from pan, and set aside.
  • Drain all except 2 Tbsp butter from pan.
  • Lightly coat meat with 2 Tbsp flour, 1/2 Tsp salt, and 1/2 Tsp pepper, and sear over high heat until just browned.
  • Remove meat from pan, and set aside.
  • Add 2 Tbsp butter to pan drippings, and blend in remaining 4 Tbsp flour, tomato paste and beef broth.
  • Cook, whisking frequently, until smooth and thickened, about 6-8 minutes, scraping bottom of pan to incorporate browned bits from meat.
  • Return meat and mushroom mixture to pan.
  • Stir in half of sour cream and half of sherry, and cook just until thoroughly heated, but do not boil.
  • Add remainder of sour cream and sherry, and blend thoroughly.
  • Serve immediately over noodles.

Questions & Replies

Got a question? Share it with the community!
Advertisement

Reviews

  1. This is a great recipe. I have lost my 5 star recipe and when I find it again will post it, but this one has many of the features of the missing one (and the missing one is more complicated and time consuming--so I liked this quicker version).<br/>I actually forgot to get mushrooms at the store, so while I was waiting for them to arrive (courtesy of my BIL) I went ahead and browned the beef. I used London Broil sliced thin. Wasn't the MOST tender, but it was still nice--had I not been in such a hurry, perhaps a little longer stewing would have made it a bit more tender. I did use a fair amount of vegetable oil to get it sufficiently browned. <br/>I omitted the Sherry because I didn't have any, though it could have used the added complexity. <br/>Still great, still tasty.
     
  2. Really really good. I only added about half the amount of sour cream because I don't like it so rich. Will make it my permanent stragonoff recipe.
     
  3. Changed a few things, left out the sherry because we don't do alcohol. I can't recall what else I didn't follow because I didn't review this until later. However what I made with a base from this recipe was good.
     
  4. This was true comfort food. A nice change & easy to put together. It was hard to find a receipe without canned soup. Added 2 extra cloves of garlic & I used a store pre-packaged beef for stir fry & found it lacking in flavour. Next time will use a top sirloin as stated in the receipe. Thanks!
     
  5. Made as written 1st time, great! @nd time I substituted milk with white vinegar allow to sit until curdled ( 1 cup to 1 tbls. ) for the sour cream. From all my research this was the correct historical way to prepare this dish. Again it was great!
     
Advertisement

Tweaks

  1. tweak by Casey I baked it covered in the oven 45-60 minutes 300 degrees so I could spend time with my guests and not in the kitchen.
     
  2. Made as written 1st time, great! @nd time I substituted milk with white vinegar allow to sit until curdled ( 1 cup to 1 tbls. ) for the sour cream. From all my research this was the correct historical way to prepare this dish. Again it was great!
     
  3. Excellent! It was my first time to do this one. It was everything the Tsar would have expected. The only change I made was to use yogurt cheese in place of sour cream. It wasn't exactly authentic but it was damn good. Thanx for posting. Pierre
     

RECIPE SUBMITTED BY

I WAS retired oilfield trash since 1999, who has lived in Houston TX for the last 25 years, though I'm originally from California. I'm Texan by choice, not by chance! I am now working in Algeria 6 months a year, so I guess that gives new meaning to the term SEMI-retired. I grew up in restaurants and worked in them for 13 years while getting through high school and college, working as everything from dishwasher to chef, including just about everything in between. At odd intervals I also waited tables and tended bar, which gave me lots of incentive to stay in school and get my engineering degree. During the 33 years since, I have only cooked for pleasure, and it HAS given me a great deal of pleasure. It's been my passion. I love to cook, actually more than I love to eat. I read cookbooks like most people read novels. My wife and I both enjoy cooking, though she isn't quite as adventurous as I am. I keep pushing her in that direction, and she's slowly getting there. We rarely go out to eat, because there are very few restaurants that can serve food as good as we can make at home. When we do go out, it's normally because we are having an emergency junk-food attack. My pet food peeves are (I won't get into other areas): are people who post recipes that they have obviously NEVER fixed; obvious because the recipe can't be made because of bad instructions, or that are obvious because it tastes horrible. I also detest people who don't indicate that a recipe is untried, even when it is a good recipe. Caveat emptor!
 
View Full Profile
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Find More Recipes