Mc Call's Cooking School Manicotti

Total Time
1hr 30mins
Prep 1 hr
Cook 30 mins

This is the most delicious manicotti EVER! The homemade noodles are like crepes, and they melt in your mouth. You won't miss the meat. We used cottage cheese in place of the ricotta. Recipe courtesy of Mccall's Cooking School 1984.

Ingredients Nutrition


  1. Make sauce: In hot oil in a 5 quart Dutch oven, saute onion and garlic 5 minutes.
  2. Mix in rest of sauce ingredients and 1 1/2 cups water, mashing tomatoes with fork.
  3. Bring to boiling, and reduce heat.
  4. Simmer mixture, covered and stirring occasionally, 1 hour.
  5. Make manicotti: In medium bowl, combine 6 eggs, the flour, 1/4 teaspoon salt, and 1 1/2 cups water with electric mixer.
  6. Beat just until smooth.
  7. Let stand 1/2 hour or longer.
  8. Slowly heat an 8" skillet. If you aren't using a skillet with a non-stick surface, brush skillet lightly with butter for each manicotti. Pour in 3 tablespoons batter, rotating the skillet quickly to spread batter evenly over bottom.
  9. Cook over medium heat until top is dry but bottom is not brown.
  10. Turn out on a wire rack to cool.
  11. Continue cooking until all of the batter is used.
  12. As the manicotti cool, stack them with waxed paper between them.
  13. Preheat oven to 350.
  14. Make Filling: In large bowl, combine ricotta, mozarrella, 1/3 cup parmesan, the eggs, salt, pepper, and parsley.
  15. Beat with wooden spoon to blend well.
  16. Spread about 1/4 cup filling down the center of each manicotti and roll up.
  17. Spoon 1 1/2 cups sauce into each of two 12x8x2" baking dishes.
  18. Place 8 rolled manicotti seam side down in single layer. Top with 5 more.
  19. Cover with 1 cup sauce and sprinkle with parmesan.
  20. Bake, uncovered, 1/2 hour or until bubbly.
Most Helpful

I have had this recipe for at least 35 years and it is excellent. In the original recipe the 1 1/2 cups water is mistakenly left out of the list of ingredients for the manicotti (it is mentioned in step 5 of the directions). For some reason every single repeat of the recipe does the same thing. I corrected it in my copy of the recipe and have always wondered why nobody else has.

Hi-desertKath February 04, 2010

I tore this recipe out of the McCalls Magazine many years ago and used it faithfully for years - the person posting says 1984 but I swear it's longer than that! LOL. It's the best one I've ever made and after all these years (like others said, 30 plus years). I know I have that torn out recipe somewhere but I just can't find it. Sooooooo pleased to find it here. I don't care if you call these Cannelloni shells or Manacotti shells they are still awesome. I always use a cheese mixture because my family never made meat filled ravaoli, lasagna or anything like that - Grandma was from Italy. I usually add about 1 Cup chopped spinach squeezed very dry to the filling for extra nutrition and color. I make my own sauce - old family recipe - and often add sausage and sometimes mushrooms to it. It's to die for! Thank you Laurel Bay - you are a life saver!

DinnerDiva March 19, 2015

OK. I've never actually written a review before, but I really want to add my praise for this dish. Like the other reviewer, I've been making it for about 35 years and usually have several manicotti casseroles, in the freezer, for unexpected company. The crepes are so much better than the store bought noodles. Also the sauce is so superior to sauce you can buy. (I use the sauce for spaghetti as well). I usually use half cottage cheese/half Ricotta. I personally like it better that way. And I often just use 4/% fat cottage cheese and leave out the ricotta completely. It's delicious and a great dish to freeze. You can put it straight from the freezer into the oven, or leave it out to thaw a bit. This recipe is very forgiving, so you can play around with it.

jilllafrance_13168289 September 22, 2013