Bergischer Sauerbraten

READY IN: 75hrs
Recipe by Tea Girl

Sauerbraten is a dish that is traditional from the Rhineland and the Bergisch region. This one is a bit of a twist on the traditional, and the sauce is so good, you will probably find yourself soaking bread in it to finish it off. It was traditionally done with horse meat, but it is more commonly done with beef now. We prefer it with roe deer, which is a small type of deer from the region but it works well with beef and horse too. It has to be done well ahead of time and it is better the longer it sits but it is not very much work for the great result. It goes well with potatoes or dumplings and red cabbage or broccoli rabé. I have taken some ideas from several recipes I found online.

Top Review by Mia in Germany

This is indeed different from the sauerbraten which I'm used to, but it is SOO good!!! You're right, the sauce is incredibly delicious. I followed the recipe to the letter - perfect directions, easy to follow, and the result is awesome. Oh, and I used both, apple butter and molasses :)<br/>Thanks so much for sharing this winner! DH is no big fan of sauerbraten, but he raved about this one.<br/>Made for PAC Spring 2014

Ingredients Nutrition


  1. Peel and cube veggies in about 1 cm pieces.
  2. In a big container with a lid, mix wine, vinegars, and spices (everything up to the sea salt), adding a pinch of sea salt and pepper.
  3. Add meat and veggies and put in refrigerator or other cool place at least 3 days and up to 10 days.
  4. Take out the meat and pat down with a towel.
  5. Heat lard or clarified butter on high heat in a lidded pot that is large enough for the meat, veggies and sauce and sear the meat on all sides.
  6. Pass the marinade through a colander, keeping both.
  7. When the meat is seared on all sides, remove and add the veggies and spices and shortly roast.
  8. Add the tomato paste and apple butter, mix and allow to caramelize for 2 minutes.
  9. Add the marinade and stock.
  10. Put the meat back on, put on lid and braise it on low heat for 1 1/2 - 2 hours (when the meat has reached 60°C/140°F).
  11. Remove meat and keep warm.
  12. Pass the liquid through colander and cook on medium-high, reducing sauce by half (about 20 minutes).
  13. Add cocoa powder and butter and salt and pepper to taste.
  14. Carve meat into slices and serve with sauce on top.

Join the Conversation

  • all
  • reviews
  • tweaks
  • q & a