" I Hate Miracle Whip, but I Love This Potato Salad That's

" I Hate Miracle Whip, but I Love This Potato Salad That's created by Andi Longmeadow Farm

I have had people who swear they hate Miracle Whip eat an ENTIRE PLATE of this potato salad. It's my mom's recipe, and you can try it with regular Mayo, but I won't stand by the results because it's so good with the Whip that I've never tried it any other way!

Ready In:
40mins
Serves:
Units:

ingredients

directions

  • Boil potatoes until tender but not mushy, set aside to cool.
  • For dressing: mix all ingredients in a bowl. Any and all of the ingredients can (and should) be adjusted to your taste as my dressing never turns out the same way twice depending on whether I'm in the mood for sweet, peppery, salty, etc.
  • Mix potatoes, celery, onion, egg, and dressing in a bowl and chill.
  • Enjoy!
Submit a Recipe Correction

MY PRIVATE NOTES

Add a Note
Advertisement
Enter The Sweepstakes
Advertisement

RECIPE MADE WITH LOVE BY

"I have had people who swear they hate Miracle Whip eat an ENTIRE PLATE of this potato salad. It's my mom's recipe, and you can try it with regular Mayo, but I won't stand by the results because it's so good with the Whip that I've never tried it any other way!"

Join The Conversation

all
reviews
tweaks
q&a
sort by:
  1. Chantity B.
    This potato salad was absolutely amazing! Will make again. I also added celery seed, red bell pepper finely chopped, and sweet relish.
  2. Pamaloo
    I put a little bit of chopped red bell pepper in mine for color, I also did half and half of yellow mustard and Dijon. Celery seed... Half a teaspoon was added, and some pickle relish. This is going to sound crazy, but my granddaughter likes Colby cheese in EVERYTHING! So, I cut up about half of a small block of cheese into small cubes and threw those in. Everyone loves it! It was perfect for our fourth of July celebration today!
  3. clyman60
    This recipe is very similar to the old-school version my mom always made, except that she had a habit of adding very thinly sliced fresh radishes if they were available (and absolutely crispy-fresh) and then garnishing with plenty of paprika. Another tip to avoid the leftovers from getting watery once refrigerated: make sure to drain the boiled potatoes very well once they've initially cooled and stir up all of the wet ingredients thoroughly.
  4. Brownjk28
    Lately when I make my potato salad with miracle whip and it lasts more than one day, it gets watery. What am I doing wrong?
  5. Karen S.
    This is the best potato salad I've ever made. Definitely my go to recipe from now on. I'm going to use it to make my macaroni salad to from now on!
Advertisement

Find More Recipes