Double Decker Fudge

"This is a family favorite and a must for the holidays."
photo by a user photo by a user
Ready In:
2hrs 30mins
4 pounds




  • Line a 13x9x2-inch pan with foil.
  • Place 1 cup peanut butter chips in medium bowl; set aside.
  • In a second medium bowl, blend 1/4 cup melted butter, cocoa and vanilla until smooth; add remaining 1 cup peanut butter chips.
  • In a heavy 4 quart saucepan, combine sugar, marshmallow cream, evaporated milk and 1/4 cup butter. Cook, stirring constantly over medium heat until mixture comes to a rolling boil. Cook and continue stirring 5 minutes.
  • Remove from heat. Immediately add half of hot mixture to bowl with peanut butter chips only. Pour remainder into cocoa mixture; stir to blend.
  • Beat peanut butter mixture until chips are completely melted, spread evenly in prepared pan.
  • Beat cocoa mixture until chips are melted and mixture thickens. Spread evenly over top of peanut butter layer.
  • Cool; remove from pan. Remove foil; cut into squares. Store in airtight container in a cool dry place.

Questions & Replies

Got a question? Share it with the community!


  1. I found this recipe on the back of a bag of Reese's PB Chips back in the 80's. I make it every year, at Thanksgiving & Christmas. It's really foolproof as long as you give the rolling boil time. It makes enough fudge for 2 parties or lots of gifts.
  2. This recipe has been made by our family at Christmas for at least 15 years. My trick for (somewhat quickly) making a double batch: Prepare two 13x9x2 pans and prepare an entire batch of just peanut butter fudge (use the entire two cups of p.b. chips) and divide between the two pans, then do the same with the chocolate portion of the fudge. Homemade fudge takes a little time, effort, and patience, but this recipe is SO worth it. I like that this fudge recipe is timed rather than having to use a candy thermometer. Also, I have learned that cane sugar works best for all baking, but most especially when making candy. I've tried using beet sugar with this recipe but it came out gritty and didn't quite set up correctly.


I LOVE to cook and eat and read cookbooks. My kitchen really does overfloweth with them and of course this has quickly become my favorite cooking site! I live with my husband in a small town in eastern Connecticut. We are both retired. My children are all grown and have families of their own now. Our 3 grandchildren and 1 great-granddaughter all live in Florida and it goes without saying that we miss them very much, so when my husband retired last year we celebrated by buying a small RV! We so enjoyed driving it to Florida to spend the holidays with the little ones. Although COVID has prevented us from repeating the trip this year, I am enjoying learning new recipes to make in our RV for next year. I think the Instant Pot and the Crock Pot will be my new best friends while traveling!
View Full Profile

Find More Recipes