Idiot-Proof Yorkshire Puddings

READY IN: 35mins
Recipe by Noo8820

This is more of a formula than a recipe. You can use any measure you like, as long as they are all the same. I just used a cup for ease of demonstration. Once you know how to do it there is no excuse for buying those horrible frozen jobs ever again (as my husband says-they are for people who are too stupid to mix together flour, eggs and milk!) You can also freeze these, then just pop them from the freezer into a hot oven for a few minutes to heat through and crisp up. I make little mini ones for the children and freeze them-a great standby for a quick dinner or a cheats 'Toad in the Hole’. Try it--you'll be wanting to eat roasts more often!

Top Review by JustJanS

Noo, I made these tonight for Russ and I and they were sensational!! I used 1 egg=1/4 cup and went from there. I made 3 and had to use oil. I was torn between using a splodge or a splash (of oil) but went with the splash (as opposed to the blob of lard) and that measurement worked perfectly for me ;-) I wasn't going to photograph them due to your lovely photo, but they looked too good not to! I made these in a half cup muffin tins and cooked them for 15 minutes.

Ingredients Nutrition


  1. Mix together the flour, eggs and milk, until well combined. Cover and leave in the fridge for as long as possible-24 hours is good, 60 minutes minimum.
  2. Melt blobs of lard/dripping or oil in pudding tin holes-enough that when its melted it comes up the side of the hole about 1/2cm.Remember lard has a higher smoke point than oil, and dripping more than lard, and in this case the hotter you can go, the better.
  3. Heat the pan in a HOT oven, until oil/lard or dripping is smoking hot. If need be, heat the pan over a flame over the stove to get it smoking.
  4. Remove batter from the fridge and mix quickly, pour into pudding holes. It should sizzle immediately.
  5. Place tray in hot oven and do not open the door. Four large puddings take about 20-25 minutes.
  6. NB-you can eat these cold with jam too!

Join the Conversation

  • all
  • reviews
  • tweaks
  • q & a