Total Time
Prep 4 mins
Cook 8 mins

I love tomato and mayonnaise on a sandwich, and I also love grilled cheese, which makes this a perfect sandwich!

Ingredients Nutrition


  1. Add butter to the outsides of the bread.
  2. Lay down one slice in stovetop pan, add the 2 slices of cheese, then lay down other slice of bread on top of cheese.
  3. Cook in the pan till it is a perfect grilled cheese -- about 7-9 minutes.
  4. Put grilled cheese on plate and immediately pull the two pieces of bread apart.
  5. Lay the tomato down on the cheesiest side.
  6. Add 3-4 tbs (big heaping spoons) of mayonnaise to other side and smooth out until you have a very thick layer of mayonnaise.
  7. You can now add the onion (*which is good but optional*).
  8. You can also add the lettuce (*optional; I have never added lettuce before, but I am sure it is good, but I would just add mayonnaise and tomato first [and onion if you want]*).
  9. I add a little salt & pepper to the tomatoes.
  10. Now lay the mayonnaise cheese bread down on top of the tomatoes for an extremely delicious sandwich!
Most Helpful

This is AWESOME!! It was definitely the best sandwich I have ever made in such a short amount of time (note: I didn't use the onions). This sandwich was so great, that I made an account specifically to rate this. IT WAS AMAZING.<br/><br/>Thank You!!

SophiaMartinez November 16, 2013

Pretty good recipe. Definitely a lot better than the grilled cheese deluxe from Cheesers. Yeah it is!!!

pgange July 20, 2013

Yummy! I used all the options and had a nice lunch! I used my homemade bread and cheddar cheese. Thank you Chef Sunshine!

Sharon123 October 04, 2005