Jimmy Carter Cake II

"This is one of my dad's altered versions of JC Cake. He is always expected to make it for family gatherings at home and at church. He has made it many different ways and this is the favorite. I guess he's been making this cake for 15 years or more. edited 09/12- note- I just made this today and had to tweak the recipe a bit. Dad is getting old and his directions were minimal. But now I've made it and made the recipe easier to follow."
photo by Chef Mommie photo by Chef Mommie
photo by Chef Mommie
Ready In:
1hr 5mins




  • Mix brownie mix according to pkg. directions and add nuts.
  • Prep a 9x13 pan according to pkg. directions.
  • Bake until set.
  • While brownies are cooling- beat together cream cheese, peanut butter, and cool whip.
  • Slowly add in confectioners sugar.
  • Beat until smooth.
  • Spread on top of brownie.
  • Beat together vanilla pudding, choc. pudding and 3 cups milk until thickened. (about 2 minutes)(this can be messy so use a deep bowl).
  • Spread on top of cream cheese mixture.
  • Top with cool whip. Sprinkle with nuts. Drizzle with chocolate syrup.
  • Refridgerate (better the second day).

Questions & Replies

default avatar
Got a question? Share it with the community!


  1. robingracejohnson
    This was soooo yummy! I made this for our dessert for the week and everyone in my family loved it! Who couldn't love this!?! It has it all; fudgy brownie bottom, peanutbutter pie-ish layer, chocolate pudding layer, with cool whip on top!!! I will definately be making this again!!! Thanks for sharing this recipe! :)
  2. Jilly in Michigan
    This was awesome! My DH & DS both said this was a keeper. I didn't have any peanuts so I used walnuts and it was the only substitution that I used. We will make this again.
    I tried this last week-end after my DH went off of his diet and it was out of this world, He wanted to know if he could hide it so he could keep it all for himself.
  4. mollyvf
    Really great and easy to make. A very impressive recipe. Thank you so much for sharing it.
  5. memakezo
    Do you have a recipe for sweet freezer pickles?


<p>I want to thank those of you who try my recipes and also the ones that submit pictures. I truly am excited to receive each and every one of them. May you&nbsp;be ever so&nbsp;blessed! Tina</p>
View Full Profile

Find More Recipes