Garbage Cookies

"You can do anything with these cookies and they are still great! Use any combo of cake mix and pudding that your heart desires and they are so simple that the kids can mix them up!"
photo by a user photo by a user
Ready In:
5-6 dozen


  • 1 cake mix (vanilla, butter pecan, chocolate, lemon or whatever)
  • 2 (3 1/2 ounce) boxes instant pudding mix (vanilla, butterscotch, chocolate, lemon or whatever)
  • 1 cup flour
  • 1 23 cups mayonnaise
  • 34 cup chopped nuts (optional)
  • 12 12 ounces butterscotch chips (whatever) or 12 ounces miniature M&M's chocolate candies (whatever)


  • Mix it all together in a large bowl.
  • Drop by rounded teaspoonfuls on ungreased cookie sheet.
  • Bake at 350 for 15 minutes.
  • Cool on rack.

Questions & Replies

default avatar
Got a question? Share it with the community!


  1. CharJoyLet
    These went quickly at work. I used Orange Supreme cake mix, French Vanilla pudding and mini-M&Ms. Mine also took 15 minutes to bake. (After looking at the time summary above, I think maybe the 5 minutes listed in the directions could be a typo.) This is a possibility for Christmas present bundles. Thanks Laurie!
  2. Ducky
    Super easy and quite tasty. Everyone gobbled these right up. I used a devil's food cake mix without pudding, chocolate pudding and raspberry chips (10 oz). The cookies stay a little chewy since they are more cake-like. The dough is a bit stiff and difficult to mix after a bit. I also had difficulty keeping the chips in the dough. It took 15 minutes to bake my cookies, not the 5 minutes stated in the recipe. I got 70 cookies. Thanks for a super easy recipe.


<p>Before I get to the details let me tell you how I rate recipes.....and tell you how I feel about others ratings! <br /> <br />5 STARS....This recipe was excellant, we liked it very much, the directions were very clear and if I made any minor substitutions I noted it. It would most likely be made again, many times! <br /> <br />4 STARS....This recipe was good, we liked it but I made changes either in taste or it was not clear in something, but I would consider making it again. <br /> <br />3 STARS....This recipe was not something that got approval from the majority. Either it just didnt work in preparation, directions, or taste. I will tell you why and would not make it again unless I altered it much! <br /> <br />2, 1 STARS.....I DO NOT give these as I feel they are NOT worthy....especially if the recipe previously had good reviews and by my giving a low one would jeopardize the ratings. I would appreciate this reciprocated with reviews to my recipes. <br /> <br />0 STARS....COMMENTS I will leave no stars and comments on something that did not work out for me and I will be honest and tell you why. <br /> <br />I DETEST IT WHEN PEOPLE CHANGE YOUR RECIPE OR DONT EVEN MAKE IT THEN LEAVE YOU LOW REVIEWS. PEOPLE WHO DO THAT ARE JUST BEING VINDICTIVE OR JUST PLAIN STUPIDLY CRUEL. Examples of some I've gotten would be: 1 star...This doesnt sound like something we would like 2 stars...too sweet for me, (this was on a all 5 star recipe). <br /> <br /> <br />Now for the details: <br />I was born, raised and still live in the same midwestern town where comfort food is what we thrive on, however my dream is to retire to the northwoods of Wisconsin.. (the sooner the better IMHO)! <br /> <br />I relish a recipe that is simple, quick and tastes great as I am a divorced mom to 4 very busy, active young adults (27, 25, 20 year old daughters and a 21 year old son.) Cooking time is at a premium as everyone is so busy, I never usually know who will be at my house for supper! I also try to find things that will reheat well. <br /> <br />I have worked for 30 years in the accounting field and presently semi retired. It is very nice for a change to not have to deal with the everyday stress of deadlines and office politics! It has been great cooking for pleasure, at my leisure, instead of to feed the troops! <br /> <br />Cooking relaxes me so I do it often and I love to cook for people who appreciate it. It is nothing for me to start a recipe at 10pm right before bedtime, and yes I have cooked all nite. Kind of a marathon!! <br /> <br />Cookbooks are my passion and I can't resist the ones that churches, schools etc. put together and well as the ones in the grocery stores. My collection numbers well over 2000 and where as some people go to bed with a good novel, my nightstand is full of cookbooks! <br /> <br />I love to bake and its nothing for me to make 15-20 different kinds of cookies and candies for the holidays. I guess that it has rubbed off on my oldest daughter who is a culinary school graduate and knee deep in pastry classes, hoping to become a pastry chef! <br /> <br />In March of 2002 I had gastric bypass, weight loss surgery and I have lost 125 pounds FOREVER, so now when I do cook it IS for everyone else to enjoy. <br /> <br />I love Zaar and all the friends I have made here, this sight is so addictive but yet so much fun! And the recipes aren't bad either..LOL! I know that in the years since Ive been a permanent fixture of this site I have acquired many great recipes and tons of cooks that I am proud to call my friends! I have also tried many foods that years ago I would never have even imagined.</p>
View Full Profile

Find More Recipes