Beef Rib-Eye Roast With Potatoes, Mushrooms and Pan Gravy

"You have selected a wonderful cut of beef, rib-eye roast is a whole cut of beef before it has been cut in to rib-eye steaks, follow the directions on this recipe and you will have a perfectly-cooked roast! --- plan well ahead the roast must be brought down to almost room temperature before cooking and this will take a few hours or more --- cooking time stated on this recipe is for a 4-pound roast and is only approximate, for a perfectly cooked roast a meat thermometer is required --- use not more than the stated amount of salt or it will draw out the juices form the meat when cooking"
photo by Dreamgoddess photo by Dreamgoddess
photo by Dreamgoddess
photo by Dreamgoddess photo by Dreamgoddess
Ready In:
2hrs 10mins




  • Make slits in the roast and stuff it with garlic slices all over (you may do this the24 hours in advance).
  • Rub the roast all over with olive oil, then season with salt and pepper.
  • Place the roast in a shallow roasting pan, fat side up.
  • Allow the beef to come down to almost room temperature (this will take about 2-1/2 hours).
  • Set oven to 350 degrees F.
  • Pour 1/4-1/3 cup beef broth in the bottom of the pan.
  • Insert a meat thermometer into the center of the roast.
  • Cook the roast for 40 minutes.
  • After the 40 minutes of cooking the roast, toss the potatoes in oil and then add to the pan, stirring to coat with the meat juices, then season the potatoes with salt and pepper, continue to cook for about 20 minutes.
  • After 20 minutes of cooking, add in the mushrooms to the pan, stirring to coat with the juices, and then continue to cook for another 40-50 minutes, depending on how you like your roast (your thermometer should read about 130F).
  • Remove the roast to a cutting board, and transfer the potatoes and mushrooms to a platter.
  • Pour the pan juices into a small saucepan and skim off any fat accumulated on top.
  • Pour the 2 cans of beef broth into the pan juices and bring to a boil; lower heat and let simmer for 3 minutes.
  • Mix together the soft butter and flour in a small cup, the add into the saucepan with the tomato paste; whisking gently to combine.
  • Slice the beef and serve with gravy, mushrooms and potatoes.
  • Delicious!

Questions & Replies

default avatar
Got a question? Share it with the community!


  1. annye
    Good rich, natural flavor! The mushrooms take on a nice deep intensity as well. I made the gravy from the pan drippings instead (pour off pan drippings into a fat-separator, return 3 T. of the fat to pan, add 3 T. flour, stir and cook 2 minutes, and thicken with de-fatted drippings, simmer, add broth as necessary.) Great for a special dinner for meat-and-potatoes fan husband! Thanks!
  2. bullwinkle
    Delicious! made this for my son's birthday. It was very tender and moist. The gravy was great. Everyone liked it, Thanks Kittencal for a delicious recipe. Bullwinkle
  3. miltt
    Great roast recipe Kitten! We all ate until we were poppin at the seams! So good. Loved the gravy. Made plenty of potatoes for us all. This is a winner and a definite repeat performance to be made soon! Milt
  4. Dreamgoddess
    I made this recipe using a chuck roast and the aroma as it cooked was heavenly. I didn't have any whole garlic cloves, so I just sprinkled some minced garlic on the roast. The flavor was delicious and the pan gravy is a must. Thanks for sharing this recipe!



Find More Recipes