Made This Recipe? Add Your Photo
Prep 10 mins
Cook 0 mins
This recipe comes from a dear friend who lived in Metro D.C. It keeps in the refrigerator for several weeks.
- Defrost ice cream.
- Mix first 5 ingredients.
- Add vanilla to taste.
- Store in closed container(s) in refrigerator. Plastic milk jugs work well for this.
- Sprinkle nutmeg on top of individual glasses of eggnog before serving.
My mother-in-law has guarded this recipe for the last 20 years. Not until she had a heart attack was I let in on the secret. This nog is the best ever. If you don't like the first glass, by the time you hit the second and third you will not remember the first. This is the best nog recipe ever.
I found this recipe seven or eight years ago and made up 3 gallons of it. It is amazing. The comment on the original recipe I saw said this is the first egg nog served to the press corps where all the cups in the room ended empty. Everyone who has tried it in my circle of friends and family have loved it. Contrary to the comment that is with the recipe, I have kept this mix in my refrigerator for years. It just gets smoother and smoother each year. I am drinking from a batch I made 2 years ago right now and it is wonderfully smooth and tasty. I guess all the booze keeps it from spoiling...