Made This Recipe? Add Your Photo

Total Time
1hr 20mins
Prep 20 mins
Cook 1 hr

There are a lot of buckeye candy recipes floating around out there, but I have found this one to be the best. Very popular during the holidays especially. One warning, once served they will be devoured before you can blink an eye.

Ingredients Nutrition

Directions

  1. Blend sugar, peanut butter and butter together thoroughly.
  2. Roll mixture into walnut-sized balls and insert a toothpick into each.
  3. Place balls on a waxed paper lined cookie sheet and then put them in the freezer for about 10 minutes, or until firm.
  4. Melt chocolate and paraffin in a double boiler.
  5. Holding onto the toothpick, dip each chilled peanut butter ball into the melted chocolate, leaving a small round area near the toothpick. This will be the "eye" of the buckeye. The dipping of each ball should be done quickly so the warm chocolate does not thaw the peanut butter too much. This can cause the ball to slide off the toothpick and into the chocolate.
  6. Place a fresh liner of waxed paper on the cookie sheet and put the buckeys on it. Refrigerate at least one-half hour before serving. You can then place the buckeyes in a container. For best results, keep them refrigerated until you serve them.
Most Helpful

3 5

I followed the instructions exactly, but the texture of the peanut butter mixture was way too dry. Since it was the first time I've made them (but not the first time I've eaten them) I thought maybe it was okay and proceeded to press the mixture together into crumbly balls. the resulting candy has a good flavor but is way too dry. I'm going to try again doubling the butter and maybe adding some vanilla extract.