Prep 10 mins
Cook 1 hr
This is how my Lebaneese in-laws make delicious yogurt at home. It's really easy, and much cheaper than buying it in the store. You can make as much or little as you like- we usually do a gasllon at a time.
- Pour the milk into a pot. Heat the milk until it is almost boiling, stirring with a metal spoon. You'll see small bubbles form around the edges and steam beginning to rise.
- Check the temperature- it should be around 180-185°F You can use a candy thermometer if you want. Remember to heat slowly and stir often to prevent scorching.
- Allow the milk to cool at room temperature. Stir frequently in order to accurately check the temperature. In Lebanon, they cool it till they can stick their pinky finger in for 10 seconds, but it's better to use a thermometer. It should reach 112°F.
- Don't proceed until the milk is below 120F(49C), and don't allow it to go below 90F (32C). 105-110 (41-43) is optimal.
- Add nonfat dry milk, if desired. Nonfat dry milk will thicken and increase the nutritional content of the yogurt.
- Add the starter. The first time you make your own yogurt, use store-bought plain yogurt. Be certain it has "active cultures" on the label. For each quart of your cooled milk, you'll need 2 tablespoons of yogurt. When I make it using a gallon of milk, I add one whole single serving container. Let the starter yogurt sit at room temperature while you are waiting for the milk to cool. This will prevent it from being too cold when you add it inches.
- Allow the yogurt bacteria to incubate. Keep the yogurt warm to encourage bacteria growth (between 105F and 122F (41C and 49C) is ideal). I just put the lid on the pot and wrap it in heavy towels, but you can use your oven, just make sure the thermometer is accurate. You'll need to use your candy thermometer and perhaps turn your oven on and then off again periodically or keep the oven light on to warm. Most ovens don't have set temperatures this low. To check the oven temperature, place your thermometer into a bowl of water inside the oven. Wait until the yogurt is thick, about the consistency of pudding.
- Important: Keep the yogurt still during this process. Jiggling won't ruin it, but it makes it take a lot longer. It can take anywhere from 8-14 hours to incubate. The longer it incubates, the thicker and more tangy the final yogurt will be.
- Refrigerate the yogurt. Place the yogurt in your fridge for several hours before serving. It will keep for 1-2 weeks. If you are going to use some of it as starter, use it within 5-7 days, so that the bacteria still have growing power. Whey, a thin yellow liquid, will form on the top. You can pour it off or stir it in before eating your yogurt.
- Don't get discouraged if it turns out a little runny your first time (mine did). You can always put a cheese cloth in a strainer to drain some of the excess fluid.
I've made this several times now and it has turned out well every time. Thanks for the clear and specific instructions!<br/><br/>Edited to add more details from my experience: I have made this too many times to count now, and never had a failure. I make my yogurt in a large heavy pot, using skim milk and a candy thermometer. You must do the initial scalding step. It doesn't have as much to do with pasteurization as it has to do with properly preparing the proteins in the milk so that they'll coagulate. To incubate my yogurt I heat my oven to 110 degrees F. (it's a well-insulated self-clean type oven) then turn it OFF, cover the pot with a lid and set it in the oven and let it sit, undisturbed, overnight. In the morning I strain it through a strainer lined with a piece of unbleached cotton until it reaches the consistency I like which is quite thick.<br/>I have also discovered that you can freeze the live culture and it will stay live, so I scoop out enough of my newly prepared yogurt to fill four sections in a regular ice cube tray, freeze them, then pop them out and store in a freezer bag in the freezer until the next time I make yogurt. At that time I pull out the cubes and let them sit in a bowl at room temperature to thaw, then stir them up a little and use as directed.
I've been attempting this recipe many times and thought it would only be fair to write a review for it! I will hold off on stars though until I can get consistant results.
First of all, I have a yogurt incubator so I know I have the temperature right. I think the biggest challenge has been to find a good starter. Also I started to get lazy and skip the scalding step. I had read that scalding was only necessary "back in the day" before pasteurization. BUT ever since skipping that step, I have not had the yogurt set up. So the next time I try, I will scald it first. I am just not patient and it is tedious to wait for it to come back down to the right temperature!