Total Time
Prep 10 mins
Cook 9 mins

I was making this for someone else and wasn't sure how picky they would be so I decided to stick with something simple. It kind of brings to mind less is more, and you don't have to add more ingredients to have something that tastes delicious. This got rave reviews, and even I loved it although I expected to be bored with it. I tripled the recipe and there were no leftovers. Great sandwich. Recipe courtesy of the Settlement Cookbook 1965. Don't forget to check my recipe for boiled eggs to make this even simpler.

Ingredients Nutrition


  1. Chop the hard-cooked eggs.
  2. Season with salt and pepper and moisten with mayonnaise.
Most Helpful

Been making this forever this way. I like to melt a slice of cheese in my sandwich with it.

seal angel December 18, 2013

My family loves egg salad like this. Nice and simple for my picky daughter and hubby. I use miracle whip to add that extra zing to it. My daughters best friend loves this so much she always request I make it for her when she comes over.

Homey December 16, 2013