Toasted Marshmallow Shake - Good Stuff Eatery, Washington D C

"Published on"
photo by AZPARZYCH photo by AZPARZYCH
photo by AZPARZYCH
Ready In:




  • On a medium-size cookie sheet, place 1/2 bag of marshmallows in a row.
  • Place under your broiler in the oven for 2 to 3 minutes, until charred. Take out of oven and let cool. (The charred marshmallows will be blended into the milkshakes.).
  • Repeat this step but only let the marshmallows toast. Take out of oven and let cool. (Reserve the toasted marshmallows to top the milkshakes.)
  • In a blender, pour milk, sour cream, ice cream and charred marshmallows.
  • Mix for 5 minutes.
  • Pour in a large glass and top with 2 to 3 toasted marshmallows.

Questions & Replies

default avatar
Got a question? Share it with the community!


  1. seesko
    This was so unique. It is hard to describe this. I wish I still had a premium membership, so I could post a picture. Be careful when cooking the marshmallows they can burn very quickly. I had to throw out my first batch. This is a must try.
  2. It's Good to be Queen!
    I have had this milk shake so when I saw this recipe I knew that it was going to go into that "MUST TRY" file. Can't wait to compare and I'll be back to rate it! If it's even close to being as good as Good Stuff's, it'll get a thumbs up in my book!
    This is really good! I LOVE the smell and taste of toasted marshmallows! The sour cream helped balance out some of the sweet, but did not overpower. Made for PRMR.


I love cooking for family and friends. I especially enjoy is like combining art and science to create something extraordinary. I am most known for making desserts like Recipe #336060. My pet peeve: when people sign-up to bring dessert to a pot-luck or dinner party and they bring something pre-made from the store. My friends and family now know to always let me bring the dessert. :) I enjoy traveling and believe that one of the best ways to experience a culture is through food. I have lived in Germany, Spain and Switzerland, and currently live in the US. My rating system: 5 stars - Excellent! Delicious! Could not be better...will make often. 4 stars - Very good! May tweak slightly. 3 stars - Good base recipe. Will need to tweak. 2 stars - Ok. Will keep looking. Cooking Contests & Games: <img src=> <img src="" border="0" alt="Photobucket"></a> <img src=""> <img src="" border="0" alt="Photobucket"> <img src=""> <img src=""> <img src=""> <img src="" border="0" alt="Photobucket"></a> <img src=""> <img src="">
View Full Profile

Find More Recipes