Prime Rib Cottage Pie (Aka Pâté Chinois in Quebec)

"So here is that start; yesterday I chose the prime rib, bones, mashed potatoes, and mashed sweet potatoes. Here is a transformation to a comfort food that you would not expect from a cut of meat like prime rib. (Hey, you could even do this with a roast if you like, I just happen to have the Lah-ti-Dah prime rib!)"
photo by a user photo by a user
Ready In:
1hr 5mins
4 pies




  • Sweat the onions, carrots and celery together with a tiny bit of canola oil; cook for 5 minutes until translucent.
  • Meanwhile, pick meat off of rib bones; chop into small pieces. I know this is a PIA, but trust me – it is worth it. You can save the bones for your next veal stock exercise. If not – freeze them anyway, because we will do it here one day!
  • Remove fat from prime rib; cut the remaining meat into small dice. You can do what you like with the fat – I like to rub it on my face for those creamy looking cheeks. (I am not serious! Give it to your dog if you like.).
  • Add meat to the pan; sweat for a minute or two to warm through.
  • Add red wine; reduce to 1/10th. Do this gently or risk toughening the meat. That would not be nice, would it?.
  • Add jus, reduce until the mixture thickens and coats the prime rib like a gravy. If you do not already love the smells of this dish, go to the doctor now, because something is wrong with you.
  • Combine potatoes together, careful not to completely combine the two. You would like to have some interest in the dish, no? Marbled looks better than orange. It might even be a conversation piece. Sure.
  • Adjust the seasoning of the potatoes and meat mixture with salt and pepper. No going back now, so get it right. Does it need more salt? Pepper?.
  • Ladle the mixture into your serving dishes. You can either go big or you can go individual.
  • Cover the meat/gravy mixture with the combined mashed potatoes; smooth to cover the meat.
  • Score the top with a fork; brush with melted butter. Don’t do it so hard you wreck your rows. Trust me, that sucks.
  • Sprinkle paprika on top of potatoes.I said sprinkle, avoid clumps. One way is with a small strainer.
  • Bake in 175 °C (350 °F) oven for 35-40 minutes or until the top is browned and the meat mixture is threatening to bubble through.

Questions & Replies

Got a question? Share it with the community!


Have any thoughts about this recipe? Share it with the community!


I have been a chef for 10 years, cooking since the ripe old age of 13.
View Full Profile

Find More Recipes