Door County Fish Boil (Sort Of.....)

"If you have never experienced an outdoor Door County Fish Boil, you have NO idea what you're missing!!! Door County is the WI penisula, north of Green Bay. It's a VERY popular tourist destination & a fish boil is an absolute must before you leave!!! Several restaurants, along with periodic civic groups, in the county serve it using delicious fresh fish from the waters of Lake Superior or Lake Michigan & it usually consists of Whitefish or Lake Trout. Many folks that don't like fish, LOVE the Door County Fish Boils. This recipe is for making it on the indoor stove instead of an outdoor fire...MUCH safer this way. NOTES:You will need a large kettle with a cover & a wire-type basket for this. FRESH fish is preferred, but frozen fish that has been thawed, can be used. If using Whitefish, be sure all scales are removed."
photo by a user photo by a user
Ready In:
1hr 15mins


  • 10 quarts water
  • 12 cup salt (can increase up to 1 cup)
  • 3 lbs potatoes (Red "B" size, scrubbed, skin-on)
  • 2 lbs white pearl onions (peeled & whole)
  • 6 -8 lbs fish (FRESH water Whitefish or Lake Trout, preferred)
  • 1 lb butter, melted (NOT margerine)
  • lemon wedge
  • fresh parsley (for garnish)


  • Stir the salt into the water & bring to a boil.
  • Place the potatoes & onions into the wire basket & lower into the boiling water.
  • When water returns to a boil, cover & boil for 15-20 minutes or until potatoes are fork tender.
  • Cut the fish in a diagonal, into about 4-5 inch chunks.
  • Remove potatoes & onions when done, drain well & empty into a bowl & keep warm.
  • Place the fish into the basket & lower into the same boiling water.
  • Be sure fish are completely submerged.
  • Cover & boil fish for approx 10-12 minutes or until fish if white & tender. DO NOT overcook.
  • Remove fish from boiling water & drain well.
  • Serve with the potatoes, onions, melted butter & lemon wedges. garnished with fresh parsley.
  • If desired, serve with freshly made cole slaw & fresh rolls or bread.
  • ENJOY!

Questions & Replies

default avatar
Got a question? Share it with the community!


Have any thoughts about this recipe? Share it with the community!


<p><strong>The only thing I like better than cooking, is eating! I learned a lot about cooking from my Dad &amp; an ornery old Norwegian cook, that I used to work for. <br />I don't get into fancy foods...just good ol' down-home, stick-to-your-ribs vittles...I'm a COOK...NOT a Chef! I <span>LUV</span> to bbq &amp; grill!!<img title=Cool src=/tiny_mce/plugins/emotions/img/smiley-cool.gif border=0 alt=Cool /> Except for pies, I don't do much baking, such as cookies, bars or cakes...that's the wife's dept. &amp; believe me, she does a mighty FINE job!!! <br />I'm a firm believer that flavored coffee &amp; flavored beer should be OUTLAWED &amp; I will NOT eat Lima Beans or Lutefisk...YUK!!! <img title=Yell src=/tiny_mce/plugins/emotions/img/smiley-yell.gif border=0 alt=Yell /><br />Our favorite place to eat is Old Abe's...a local supper club located on a wooded back-road! We also enjoy Panera Bread, Dickey's BBQ &amp; Picanha Brazillian Steak House!!!<br />I've been married since 1977 to the most wonderful lady a man could ever ask for. We have 9 beautiful Grandkids...5 girls 4 boys, a VERY SPOILED white German Shephard (Tori) &amp; a VERY goofy cat (Angel)! (Both of these are rescued animals.) <br />We collect antique gasoline engines &amp; attend several shows here in the Midwest.I also enjoy ice fishing, Milwaukee Brewers baseball, WI Badger football, but most of all, we're HUGE GREEN BAY PACKERS Fans!!!!! GO PACK GO!!!!!</strong></p> 8724987"
View Full Profile

Find More Recipes