All American Steak Sandwich

"Meat, potatoes, and vegetables all in one terrific sandwich. The gem? Made all in one pan. Enjoy! (Made for RSC #16)"
photo by Baby Kato photo by Baby Kato
photo by Baby Kato
photo by Baby Kato photo by Baby Kato
Ready In:




  • SAUCE: Mix all sauce ingredients well, cover and set aside.
  • POTATOES: Heat oil in a skillet to 350°F Add sliced potatoes and fry, turning occasionally, until done (about 7-10 min). Drain potatoes on paper towels, and sprinkle lightly with salt.
  • ROLLS: To the pan with oil, reduce heat to medium and add the butter. When melted, add the garlic and cook 2-3 minutes until garlic is tender.
  • Place the cut side of the rolls face down into the garlic butter. Press gently to coat. Place rolls onto a baking sheet, butter side up. Broil in oven or toaster oven until nicely browned and toasted. Remove from broiler and set rolls onto plates. Add a slice of Swiss cheese to the bottom bun.
  • VEGETABLES: To the pan over medium-high heat, add the peppers and onions. Cover and let steam 2-3 minutes. Remove lid, stir, and continue cooking until onions are translucent and peppers done. Place vegetables in a dish and set aside.
  • MEAT: To the pan add a bit more olive oil and butter if necessary. (enough to sear steak). Add seasoned steak and let sear for 2-3 minutes. Toss and continue searing until almost desired doneness. Add mushrooms to pan and saute' for 2-3 minutes until mushrooms are browned and flavored with the meat juices. Drain meat and mushrooms onto a paper towel.
  • ASSEMBLY: To each bottom bun, add the meat, then vegetables, then potatoes. To the top bun, spread with sauce and place over top. Grab lots of napkins, a fork (to catch what falls on the plate), and enjoy.
  • ALTERNATIVE: Wrap sandwich in foil and eat 'to go' style.

Questions & Replies

default avatar
Got a question? Share it with the community!


  1. weekend cooker
    A Very nice Sandwich. Made this for lunch for an after church Sunday lunch for the 4 of us, and doubled the recipe. I did leave out the mushrooms, other than that, a nice lunch. Definately did not mind the mess as we were eating this, because it sure WAS worth it. Made for PRMR tag.
  2. Noo8820
    A great tasting sandwich that you will end up wearing if you're not careful-not easy hanging onto all of this one, but worth the mess!<br/>Made for PRMR.
  3. Baby Kato
    Great use of contest ingredients, good luck in the Contest its an awesome sandwich. Loved this sandwich, it was so flavorful and had amazing textures. The sauce was so good, it complimented all the ingredients perfectly. The sandwich was fresh and delicious, the meat was tender, the vegetables were perfectly cooked and the potatoes were a delicious addition. This was definitely worth the extra effort. I can't wait to make this again.


Original Zaaarite. Food lovers. Lynnda passed away in March 2020. Her recipes live on here for everyone to enjoy and Rick continues the tradition. We will forever live together through our food. Live well. Eat well.?
View Full Profile

Find More Recipes