Homemade Cottage Cheese Pierogies / Perogies - the Old Fashioned

READY IN: 20mins
Top Review by lme.4savings

I tried these but found them very bland and also 'mushy' after boiling. I have never heard of a recipe for pierogies that didn't sautee them after blanching. Now I know why.lol I don't doubt this is one old fashion way, but if you add a few 'unhealthy but tasty' steps, I think you'll enjoy more. My mom and aunts were Polish and twice a year got together to make hundreds...<br/>Filling - Try regular large curd cottage cheese, instead of dry. A little hard to seal in the dough at first, but you'll get the hang of it. Then added diced onion, sauteed in margarine until limp - which gives them a GREAT flavor.<br/>And, boiling wasn't the final step...after blanching in boiling water (until they float) for a couple of minutes, they are sauteed in butter or margarine until light golden brown.<br/>OK - not the healthiest way to cook,but everyone LOVES THEM.

Ingredients Nutrition


  1. Cottage Cheese Filling: Combine the cottage cheese with the egg and season to taste with the salt.
  2. If the cheese is very dry, an additional egg (or egg yolk) or thick sour cream can be added.
  3. Mix the flour with the salt in a deep bowl.
  4. Add the egg, oil and water to make a medium soft dough.
  5. Knead on a floured board until the dough is smooth.
  6. Caution: Too much kneading will toughen the dough.
  7. Divide the dough into 2 parts.
  8. Cover and let stand for at least 10 minutes.
  9. Prepare the filling.
  10. The filling should be thick enough to hold its shape.
  11. Roll the dough quite thin on a floured board.
  12. Cut rounds with a large biscuit cutter, or as most old-world grandmothers did, with the open end of a glass.
  13. Put the round in the palm ofyour hand.
  14. Place a spoonful of filling in it, fold over to form a half circle and press the edges together with the fingers.
  15. The edges should be free of filling.
  16. Be sure the edges are sealed well to prevent the filling from running out.
  17. Place the pierogi on a floured board or tea towel and then cover with another tea towel to prevent them from drying out.
  18. COOKING: Drop a few pierogies into a large quantity of rapidly boiling salted water.
  19. Do not attempt to cook too many at a time.
  20. Stir VERY gently with a wooden spoon to separate them and to prevent them from sticking to the bottom of the pot.
  21. Continue boiling for 3-4 minutes.
  22. The cooling period will depend upon the size you made it, the thickness of the dough and the filling.
  23. Pierogies will be ready when they are puffed.
  24. Remove them with a perforated spoon or skimmer to a colander and drain thoroughly.
  25. Place in a deep dish, sprinkle generously with melted butter to prevent them from sticking.
  26. Cover and keep them hot until all are cooked.
  27. Serve in a large dish without piling or crowding them.
  28. Top with melted butter- chopped crisp bacon and/or chopped onions lightly browned in butter.
  29. REHEATING: One of the great things about pierogies, is that they can be made in large quantities, refrigerated, frozen and reheated without loss of quality.
  30. Many prefer reheated pierogies as compared to freshly boiled ones.
  31. To re-heat, you can 1) pan fry pierogies in butter or bacon fat until they are light in color or 2) heat the pierogies in the top of a double boiler or in the oven until they are hot and plump or 3) deep fry them.

Join the Conversation

  • all
  • reviews
  • tweaks
  • q & a