Easy As Pie - Lemon Pie - 5 Ingredients

Made This Recipe? Add Your Photo

Total Time
5 mins
0 mins

WOW, I grew up on this as a kid and never knew how easy it was to make. one bite and you'll see why. I begged my mom to make it ever year for the holidays.

Skip to Next Recipe




  1. mix egg yolks, milk, juice into large bowl.
  2. Mix all together until creamy.
  3. Add a few pinches of cream tartar to make it set nice. (not enough will make it runny.)
  4. Pour into your pie dish and refridgerate!
  5. Depending on the size of your crust, you may need to use more sweetened condensed milk to fill the pie up. I usually use 1 can, + 1/2 can. I always let mine set overnight. You can top it with anything you wish like whipped cream, or lemon wedges for garnish. I give one to each of my neighbors as sweet gifts. I promise you will love it!