Baked Rib Eye Steaks With Mushrooms

READY IN: 26mins
Recipe by Montana Heart Song

This is for frozen steaks. From freezer to oven to plate. This is not for thick cuts of meat. Thick cuts allow extra baking time. Everything my Mom told me "not to do" with a steak is in this recipe and it works!

Top Review by lazyme

Well, I have to say that I was very leary of baking a rib eye from it's frozen state. But I decided that I would give it a try since it would take me longer to thaw it out to cook it. I was really pleased with the way that this turned out. My steak came out just a little bit too rare for me, so I microwaved it at the end for about 45 seconds and it was perfect. I will definitely make this again and will put the mushrooms in about five minutes after the steak. Thanks Montana Heart Song for a great and simple recipe. Made for Bargain Basement Tag.

Ingredients Nutrition

  • 4 rib eye steaks
  • 12 teaspoon mccormick all seasoning or 12 teaspoon salt or 12 teaspoon garlic salt
  • Pam cooking spray
  • olive oil
  • 1 (8 ounce) cartonsliced fresh mushrooms


  1. Steak Preparation:.
  2. Take out steaks from freezer, unwrap. You might have to dip in cold water to loosen the tray and packing from meat.Do not leave the meat in the water, dip only and pull off.
  3. Spray Pam in non stick baking pans.
  4. Put two steaks in each pan.
  5. Season each steak.
  6. Preheat oven 400*.
  7. Drizzle 1/2 teaspoons olive oil over each steak.
  8. Mushroom Preparation:.
  9. Spray Pam in non-stick pan and add mushrooms.
  10. Salt as desired.
  11. Drizzle 1 teaspoons olive oil over the mushrooms, toss with spatula to mix.
  12. Place the steak pans and the mushrooms pans in the oven.
  13. Cook 20 minutes for medium rare, 25 minutes for medium to well. Do not turn the steaks.
  14. Do not cover.
  15. Turn the mushrooms once during the cooking process.
  16. Note: Cooking time will determine the thickness of the meat. I have done this with Buffalo steaks (never cook them well done.) I have also cooked Elk steak in this way.
  17. I can have supper on the table in 30 minutes. This recipe gives me time to make a salad and potatoes or pasta.

Join the Conversation

  • all
  • reviews
  • tweaks
  • q & a