Amish Peanut Butter Jelly

Total Time
Prep 5 mins
Cook 0 mins

There are several recipes for 'peanut butter jelly' in Lancaster County - this is our favorite. Measurements are never exact - it's just mixed to the desired consistency. This is often spread on bread - on top of "shmear kase" (smear/cup cheese) - see my other recipes. Enjoy!


  1. Mix peanut butter and King syrup until smooth and easily spreadable.
Most Helpful

Thanks for sharing WJKING! My Dad always made this for us growing up but I never had an EXACT recipe! Thanks for the tip!

Monica in PA June 14, 2003