Cheesy Garlic, Herb, Paprika & Tomato Muffins

"This muffin recipe is very simple, and produces a heap of tasty muffins that can be served either hot or cold. I prefer them hot, 5-10mins after they are pulled from the oven. They are perfect as a snack, lunch, brunch, afternoon tea, etc., and also particularly good for picnics (e.g. used as a substitute for bread, served alongside salads and cold meats). This recipe has by and large been taken from Alison Holst's cookbook "Meals Without Meat," however I have tweaked it here and there to improve the flavour :) Enjoy!"
photo by a user photo by a user
Ready In:
12 muffins




  • Preheat oven to 210°C.
  • Put the grated cheese, flour, salt, sugar, cayenne pepper, paprika, smoked paprika, garlic granules, and herbs into a large bowl.
  • Mix lightly with your fingertips to combine. Make a well in the center.
  • In another container, beat the egg and milk until evenly combined.
  • Pour all the liquid onto the dry ingredients.
  • Fold the two mixtures together, drawing in all the flour from the sides of the bowl until all ingredients are incorporated. Try not to overmix.
  • Grease your deep muffin pan well.
  • Spoon mixture off a tablespoon, helping it off with another spoon, into the pan. Fill each hole with as much as is needed to use up all of the batter.
  • Place a slice of tomato on top of each muffin. Lightly brush each slice with a little melted butter or oil.
  • Sprinkle with additional salt, cheese or paprika if desired.
  • Bake at 210C for about 12 minutes, or until tomato slices are cooked (they'll look a bit shrivelled), muffins spring back when pressed, and muffins look golden brown.
  • Remove from oven and set aside to cool for 5-10 minutes before removing from pan.
  • To easily remove from pan, slide a butterknife around the sides of each muffin, and then lift. Tip: If muffins are stuck, put a plate or rack on top of muffin tray and flip tray over. Smooth a wet teatowel or sponge over the base of each muffin cavity for 1 or so minutes, then give the tray a light shake. Keep spongeing and lightly shaking until all muffins have come out. This method should release your muffins from their tray without breaking.
  • Serve!

Questions & Replies

Got a question? Share it with the community!


  1. Apart from the fact that I completely forgot the tomato these tasted really nice. I think it's important to use quite strong cheese as I used very mild stuff and you barely noticed that cheese was in there. Nice recipe!
  2. We only use 1 cup of the cheese, and they are still great. My husband likes the extra flavor these have. I like the color they add to the dinner table.
  3. I made these yesterday and they were really easy to put together, Great just out of the oven and I froze the remainder... I microwaved one this morning for breakfast and it was nice and moist. The tomato topping was different but definitely stirred the tastebuds.. I didn't have smoked paprika and think I will add some ham next time even though the recipe came from meals without meat.


<img src=""> I love cooking. I enjoy organic gardening and finding new ways to use my homegrown produce. I have a good knowledge of a number of regional cuisines, particularly australian, italian, german, american, chinese, indonesian, and japanese foods. I also have an extensive knowledge and experience in vegetarian cuisine. My partner and I absolutely love cooking together, and make a lot of our own jams, pickles, preserved fruit and vegetables, sauces, stocks, dried herbs, and icecream toppings!
View Full Profile

Find More Recipes