Unbaked Cookies

Unbaked Cookies created by  Pamela

A very uninspired name, that's for sure, but I bet you'll remember them anyway once you've tried them! A recipe from 'The Mennonite Treasury of Recipes,' this is still a favourite among every Mennonite family that I know! My mom never wanted to make these for me as a kid, I guess because they're terribly sweet (and you know how bad sugar is for kids!!), but now that I don't live under my parents' roof anymore, I can make them as often as I want. Problem is, between my husband, daughters and I, even a double batch doesn't last very long!! I usually do use a little less sugar because mom was right, they are quite sweet. Freezes really well -- if they make it to the freezer! (Yield is approximate; depends how big you make your cookies.)

Ready In:
20mins
Yields:
Units:

ingredients

directions

  • In a saucepan over medium heat, bring first 3 ingredients to a boil.
  • Cook for 3 minutes, stirring constantly. Remove from heat.
  • In a large mixing bowl, combine remaining ingredients and add milk/sugar/butter mixture.
  • Mix thoroughly and drop by tablespoons onto wax paper-lined cookie sheets to harden. Place in fridge or freezer to speed the process.
Submit a Recipe Correction

MY PRIVATE NOTES

Add a Note
Advertisement
Enter The Sweepstakes
Advertisement

RECIPE MADE WITH LOVE BY

@Swan Valley Tammi
Contributor
@Swan Valley Tammi
Contributor
"A very uninspired name, that's for sure, but I bet you'll remember them anyway once you've tried them! A recipe from 'The Mennonite Treasury of Recipes,' this is still a favourite among every Mennonite family that I know! My mom never wanted to make these for me as a kid, I guess because they're terribly sweet (and you know how bad sugar is for kids!!), but now that I don't live under my parents' roof anymore, I can make them as often as I want. Problem is, between my husband, daughters and I, even a double batch doesn't last very long!! I usually do use a little less sugar because mom was right, they are quite sweet. Freezes really well -- if they make it to the freezer! (Yield is approximate; depends how big you make your cookies.)"

Join The Conversation

all
reviews
tweaks
q&a
sort by:
  1. less2saw
    I make these cookies whenever my oven is overworked. You can substitute in 1/2 cup of chopped nuts if you take out the same amount of oats. I now use oatmeal blend porridge cereal that has flax and oat and wheat germ in it. I also add 1/2 teaspoon of salt because my recipe calls for it. I love this cookie, my grandson didn't believe it would be a cookie at all without going into the oven. Fantastic. Thanks for having it here, saves me typing it out! :) NOTE: My recipe only calls for 2 cups oatmeal and 1/2 cup coconut, 1/2 cup chopped nuts. So the dry mixture is slightly smaller than this recipe. The cookie is never dry.
  2. iglowforyou
    Chewy and fudgy. I'm from Saskatchewan and these cookies are pretty common here, I can't imagine anyone not knowing them. I like them chewy, "shiny".. I have had many batches come out drier than I like and crumbly. The poster who said that cooking time is everything was bang on. I started timing just when it came to a rolling boil, dumped in my dry ingredients at 3 minutes and removed from heat right away. I also cut sugar to 1.5c and added about half cup of peanut butter. Perfect! Thank you!
  3. nbsd_mom
    Very good, came out perfectly and tasted just like mom's...will also try this with peanut butter which was another version my mom made.
  4. Lori Alcorn
    Yeah, I finally found the version of this recipe that my mom used, I kept finding one with chinese noodles in it, not rolled oats! My diet just may suffer now that I've found this recipe: )
  5. Trish Za Dish
    These cookies are a family tradition growing up in my home. A family with 6 kids, often we'd have to make a triple batch and it would be gone in minutes. I too am from Alberta Canada and know this recipe is known in every household that I know of. I know this recipe by heart. A note to the person who had that dry batch, COOKING TIME IS EVERYTHING!!! It was cooked either too long or at too high of temp. I've done that, and also had it come out soupy... My method is 5 mins at rolling boil at medium heat.
Advertisement

Find More Recipes