The Godfather of Grilled Cheese Sandwiches

"There are times in our daily lives when we just have a case of the blues & nothing is as therapeuitc for it as a grilled cheese sandwich - the ultimate comfort food! This unique grilled cheese sandwich uses blue to cure the blues & puts a bit of an Italian twist on an otherwise British effort .. hence the Godfather title. I can't recall now where the idea originated, but I've been playing w/it for quite a while & have modified it from the original to suit our preferences. I suggest you try it - it may work well as a blues preventative for you too!"
photo by threeovens photo by threeovens
photo by threeovens
photo by lazyme photo by lazyme
photo by BarbryT photo by BarbryT
photo by Redsie photo by Redsie
photo by Redsie photo by Redsie
Ready In:
4 Grilled Sandwiches


  • 4 ounces cream cheese (softened)
  • 2 ounces blue cheese (crumbled)
  • 3 ounces bacon (cooked crisp & crumbled)
  • 3 ounces fresh tomatoes (diced, use only tomato meat or pulp)
  • 4 tablespoons Italian salad dressing
  • 8 slices bread


  • Combine the cream cheese w/the blue cheese & mix well to a smooth consistency.
  • Add crisped bacon pieces & diced tomato to the cheese mixture & mix just well enough to achieve a good distribution.
  • Put 8 slices sandwich bread on your cutting board or counter. Using a pastry brush, brush approx 1/2 tbsp of the Italian salad dressing on ea slice of bread.
  • Turn over 4 slices of the bread & spread 3 oz of the cheese mixture on those 4 slices (You should have 12 oz of cheese mixture for this).
  • Top ea of those slices w/the other 4 slices so all the exposed bread surfaces are the ones spread w/the Italian salad dressing.
  • Grill your sandwiches & enjoy!

Questions & Replies

default avatar
Got a question? Share it with the community!


  1. JackieOhNo!
    Wow - this was outstanding (and I don't even like any type of blue cheese!). I made this exactly as posted, using gorgonzola and rye bread. Absolutely delightful. I would only caution that you let the sandwich rest for a minute or so before slicing, so the filling doesn't run out when you do so. Thanks for sharing this treat!
  2. weekend cooker
    Very good... I left out the tomato for myself, but everyone else had them. The cream cheese/bleu cheese mixture was awesome, and with the bacon on top, it hit the spot.
  3. Muffin Goddess
    I don't think I would've thought to put these ingredients together in a grilled cheese sandwich, but I'm really glad that someone else did, lol! I never would've thought to use Italian dressing as the "butter" on the outside of the sandwich, either -- learn something new every day! I used smoked blue cheese and light cream cheese in this (leftover stuff I needed to use up). I chopped my tomato and just sprinkled it on top of the cheese right before cooking. I was wrapping it to grill at work for dinner, and was afraid that the tomatoes would make the bread mushy if I mixed them into the cheese ahead of time. Thanks for posting, twissis -- this definitely cheered me up! Made for Culinary Quest I Family Picks
  4. threeovens
    Love the creamy texture alongside all that flavor! Really good!
  5. nott2339
    Very good. I just sliced my tomato and laid it on, rather than chopping and stirring it into the cheese. For my taste, I might cut back a little on the blue cheese, or use milder variety of blue.


I am an American transplanted from Dallas to Iceland by marriage to a native Icelander & I retired to become his "Kitchen Queen". We love to entertain our family & friends, so I have an eclectic collection of recipes. I especially love simple, easy-fix, flexible & make-ahead recipes - BUT also like challenging myself on occasion. I enjoy baking & food photography. I am devoted to the "More is Always Better Principle" & apply it liberally to bacon, butter & garlic. I can have ingredient issues due to availability here in Iceland & my DH is medically diet-restricted from some ingredients as well. Either situation might require me to modify a recipe, but I will do my best to be true to your recipes & fair/honest in my reviews. Mary Pat (aka twissis)
View Full Profile

Find More Recipes