The Best Butterfinger Cake

"Your family will love this chocolate cake filled with caramel, cool whip, and butterfingers. This is the most wonderful cake you will ever eat in your life. If you are on a diet go ahead and splurge it is sooooooo worth it. It is moist and just plain delicious."
The Best Butterfinger Cake created by didyb
Ready In:
1hr 30mins


  • 18 ounces German chocolate cake mix
  • 3 eggs (or as called for by your cake mix)
  • 13 cup oil (or as called for by your cake mix)
  • 1 13 cups water (or as called for by your cake mix)
  • 1 (8 ounce) container Cool Whip
  • 1 (12 ounce) jar caramel ice cream topping
  • 1 (14 ounce) can of eagle sweetened condensed milk
  • 3 (7 ounce) king size butterfinger candy bars


  • Preheat oven to temperature specified on the cake mix box.
  • Prepare the German Chocolate Cake mix as directed on the box.
  • Bake cake in a 9x13 glass cake pan, for as long as directed on the cake mix box.
  • When cake is done allow to cool until it is just barely warm.
  • When the cake is just barely warm take a wooden spoon handle and poke holes in the top of the cake. Put as many holes as you want.
  • Take carmel and drizzle over the top of the cake allowing it to run into the holes. Use the whole jar.
  • Take the sweetened condensed milk and drizzle over the top of the cake allowing it to run into the holes. Use the whole can.
  • When the cake is completely cool take the container of cool whipe and spread all over the top of the cake, until whole cake is covered. If cake isn't completely cooled the cool whip will melt and run off.
  • Crush all the butterfingers and sprinkle over the top of the cake. Then put the cake in the refrigerator until ready to server. The cake needs to be refrigerated at least 30 minutes to allow it to set up.

Join The Conversation

sort by:
  1. didyb
    The Best Butterfinger Cake Created by didyb
  2. didyb
    Very rich! I used yellow cake mix. I would say it's too sweet, but it's more of a portion control issue. Almost Tres Leches like in taste/texture. Yummy.
  3. unmistakable1
    This is one of my husband's favorite desserts, and asks me to make it every chance I can -- we call it "Great Cake" because it truly is GREAT! :) I usually do Recipe #208645 instead of the chocolate cake and it's still just as rich and delicious. I also use just two candy bars and find that's plenty for the top.
  4. Melanie Murray
    This is so easy and so delicious. I made it for my granchild's dad for a birthday surprise. HE LOVED IT! A great winner in this household. Thanks for sharing. Melanie
  5. hannahsmommma
    My Mom and a friend at work both make this cake and it is TO DIE FOR!! Everyone will ask for the recipe and it will be gone FAST!! I have also seen it made with different kinds of candy, but I think butterfingers are the best!



Find More Recipes