Substitution for Pumpkin Pie Spice

"Out of pumpkin pie spice and only need a little to get you through until you buy more? From Hamilton Beach web site a few years back."
photo by gailanng photo by gailanng
photo by gailanng
photo by Nikki Kate photo by Nikki Kate
photo by Nikki Kate photo by Nikki Kate
photo by Nikki Kate photo by Nikki Kate
Ready In:
3 teaspoons




  • Stir or shake ingredients together.
  • Store in a closed small container.
  • Use in place of"pumpkin pie spice" in your recipe.

Questions & Replies

default avatar
  1. Rita Armida A.
    If I makeep my own pumpkin pie spice mix how much do I use for 1 pie?
  2. Rita Armida A.
    If I make my own pumpkin pie spice, how much do I u see for a pie?


  1. crazy 8.
    Horible it wasn't even close to pumkin spice
  2. Big Sis
    Life saver...did not want to go to the store! Thank you!!! No need to buy yet, another spice!
  3. Anna Laurena D.
    Best pumpkin pie spice! I used it in my Pumpkin Pecan Rum Cake. Everyone LOVED it! I think it was the best Pumpkin Pecan Rum Cake I've ever made.
  4. Candace B.
    Tastes exactly like the real thing :) Perfect substation in a pinch!
  5. wanda
    Hi, i'm entering a Halloween dessert contest on Saturday and the recipe calls for, guess what? you're right 'pumpkin spice', and since I don't use this spice enough to buy it, this recipe sure does come in handy. I'll let u kno how it turned out.


I am the mother of three (one grown, one in middle school and one in high school). I have grandchildren who we invite over regularly to spend the night. We have lots of fun and a very full house! I do all of the baking and my husband cooks all the dinners. He loves to BBQ and cook and he is GOOD at it! He is wonderful with the children and I appreciate him so! I enjoy gardening, crafts, sewing, and crocheting, pets, and all kinds of "kid fun". If I had a month off I would spend it somewhere on the coast with just my sweetie and a view of the sea. I would miss the kids terribly so I would have them visit us in the hotel (that of course has room service) on Thursdays,Fridays, Saturdays, and Sundays for swimming, walks, beach-combing, dune climbing and dune buggy rides, movies, church, and the hottub!
View Full Profile

Find More Recipes