This is my mother-in-laws recipe for potato salad that my husband and his family were brought up on. They swear it has to be made with Cain's mayonaise as no other mayonaise will give the same results. Some like onions and some don't so do what your family likes. I actually use more than 12 eggs some times when I make this. It is best made the day before to let the flavors meld. It is always a hit when I make this and people can believe how easy it is.