Peanut Butter Fudge Pie

"This is a combination of a recipe Mom Meyer gave me and one I found on Zaar. The fudge layer adds some interest. I reduced the sugar and increased the peanut butter from other recipes. This is a good summer treat, and can be frozen for a while. Thaw at least a few hours before eating in the fridge or an hour before on the counter."
photo by flower7 photo by flower7
photo by flower7
Ready In:




  • Mix cream cheese until fluffy.
  • Blend in peanut butter and powdered sugar, mix well.
  • Slowly add milk.
  • Fold in 2-4 ounces of the whipped topping.
  • Set aside.
  • Spread fudge onto bottom and sides of prepared crust.
  • Put mixture into crust.
  • Freeze a few hours until just set.
  • Spread remaining whipped topping over pie.
  • Sprinkle with chocolate chips.
  • Replace lid and freeze.
  • Thaw in fridge 2 or more hours, or counter 1 hour, before serving.

Questions & Replies

default avatar
Got a question? Share it with the community!


  1. Noelle82
    I love this recipe because of the fudge layer AND the increase of peanut butter. The other pies I have tried taste more like cheesecake with a hint of peanut. This pie TOTALLY stands alone!!! Oh and I used an oreo crust as well due to my chocolate addiction!!! Thanks so much for this recipe!! I am actually making another pie now to share with my church family tomorrow!!!
  2. Cheeky Panda
    Oh wow!! I made this pie for Memorial Day weekend... and let me just say it's a good thing I made 2, because 1 definitely would not have made it to this weekend! The first pie didn't even make it til suppertime before everyone dug into it! I used flower7's Kahlua fudge sauce, too (it looked too irresistible to not try it), and instead of spreading the remaining Cool Whip on top of the pie, I made my own whipped cream with the remaining of my Kahlua and heavy cream-- yummy!!! Thanks!
  3. flower7
    This is wonderful! I made my own hot fudge - Recipe #130571 - and used light cream cheese, fat free cool whip, and skim milk - but you'd never know! Very rich! I also used an oreo crust instead of graham cracker. Drizzled with a little extra fudge sauce when serving. Thanks so much for sharing!
  4. fritzy
    omg...this pie is 2 die 4:)...yum-o.......dh loved this & he doesnt eat wanted the only piece that was left 2 take home......the only thing i did different was i didnt have the fudge so i squirted hersheys syrup over the bottom(next time i'll use the fudge)..and i used the large whipped topping 1/2 in the pie and 1/2 on the top...topped with broken up pb cups.....and this is going to be my summer pie, all smmer long.....thanks for a great recipe (and so easYp.s. oh yeah and i used a oreo crust (the pre made ones)
  5. ilovemyfamily
    Five stars! Easy to make, and very delicious! Made it for Memorial Day. Family loved it. I could only eat a small piece due to the fact that it is very rich. Will make again. Used store bought hot fudge (warm it in the microwave for 15-30 sec to easily spread in crust).



Find More Recipes