Peanut Butter Cake Frosting

"A quick and easy frosting that will cover a two layer cake."
photo by lilsweetie photo by lilsweetie
photo by lilsweetie
Ready In:
1 2layer cake




  • In bowl of mixer, beat together peanut butter, butter or margarine, and shortening, until creamy.
  • Mix in vanilla and 2 Tablespoons milk.
  • Slowly add powdered sugar, and with the mixer on medium beat until reaches desired consistency.
  • Add more milk, 1 teaspoon at a time, if needed.
  • Beat until fluffy.

Questions & Replies

Got a question? Share it with the community!


  1. OUTSTANDING! Screwed up a brownie mix so it was more or less chocolate cake with peanut butter cups in it and wanted a peanut butter topping to cover my boo boo...what an awesome frosting!! I confess...putting some in a small bowl and hiding away with it sounds tempting!! Even the pickiest loved it!!
  2. I made this last night to frost a chocolate cake. It was so good. I did have to add more milk because I 'dumped' the powdered sugar in all at once. I also added chopped peanuts on top after frosting. I will make this again, only next time I will keep some out, just to eat!


Zaar...Wow, what a place! I'm one of the old timers of Zaar. I can't count the number of wonderful dishes I cooked in the past few years since joining. Along the way I have had the pleasure of meeting several Zaar chefs. Talk about your fruits and nuts! lol. I have enjoyed meeting them all. Family: What's to say...I have had the same sweet husband forever (Good thing....I'd hate to have to break a new one in...=) and live close to a couple of grown children. (Maybe you've met Smoke Alarm Jr. ..her brown rolls are sooo good!) Therefore, my family gets together often to enjoy each other's company and cooking. My greatest joy is six "little to tallerthanme" kids running around calling me Grammy. They wear me out! lol For the past thirty years I have been a Special Education teacher for grades 9-12 and love it. Took some time off last year to recovery from surgery, chemotherapy and radiation for breast cancer. (Loved the radiation....I keep imagining that we are absolutely napalming the nasty cancer cells tohellandback to keep the little suckers from returning. =) My prognosis is good and now "I'm back in the saddle again". lol. Being a north country "gurl", I am happiest outside...walking, fishing, sitting in front of an outdoor fire or being on water (although in February it's a bit stiff....=0) When indoors I like to read, garden, knit, quilt and paint. During cold Maine weather I like to warm my feet on a very large ( 100 pounds of long legs and huge feet), sweet and furry golden retriever named Kerry (aka KTBRD: Kerry the big red . In the summer, the dawg and I round up the grandkids, hit the local dairy bar for a Mounds Sundae that is to die for!!!=0) . Then spend a lot of long and lazy summer days at camp . All in all...Boy, Life is good! =)
View Full Profile

Find More Recipes