Kittencal's Creamy Greek-Style Pasta Salad

"If you are a lover of Greek salad and Greek food then you are certain to enjoy this --- once you make this a few times you will most likely need to play around with the dressing ingredient to suit taste, I have listed 1/3 cup mayonnaise to be added to the dressing you may need to adjust the mayonnaise amount to desired creaminess after the salad is mixed --- plan ahead this salad needs to chill for at least 4 hours before serving"
Kittencal's Creamy Greek-Style Pasta Salad created by Andi Longmeadow Farm
Ready In:




  • Cool the pasta in boiling water until al dente; drain then rinse well under cold water.
  • Place the pasta in a large bowl.
  • Add in cucumber, tomatoes, bell pepper, onion, olives and cubed feta cheese; toss to combine.
  • For the dressing; in a processor place the garlic clove and process until minced.
  • Add in all the remaining ingredients except the mayonnaise;process until well blended (about 20-30 seconds) then add in the mayonnaise and process until combined.
  • Pour over the salad ingredients in the bowl; toss to combine (if you prefer a creamier salad then add in more mayonnaise to taste).
  • Cover and refrigerate for at least 4 hours.

Join The Conversation

sort by:
  1. zolabebe
    Fantastic! Tried a greek pasta salad at my local deli and was determined to come home and make my own. This one is even better than what I tried! I went heavy on the garlic, mayo and pepper. Also used a penne pasta and roasted red bell pepper. Thank You!!!!
  2. tarab5
    This was okay, but it just didn't wow me.
  3. Keee8698
    Really good! I veganized it by omitting the feta and substituting vegenaise for the mayo - my non-vegan husband sprinkled feta on his at the end. We ended up having to add more mayo the next day because it really dried out but that might be because I used quinoa pasta.
  4. zsazsa71
    Susan u r rite!!!! This was execellent!! Just got a Vitamix unit last week, used it to combine the dressing ingredients. Used only 2 tbsps of mayo thined with 3tbsps of pasta water. Also went back and made dressing again to marinate chicken breasts for me and the girls and salmon for my husband. Sent a "taste test" bowl to my mother she came over with her own bowl!! ( Kittencal I also make ur shortbreads, ur my best friend in my head)!
  5. susanrogers228_8537
    Oh my goodness! This was just the best recipe ever. I haven't been able to stop eating it. Someone dial 911!! The only things I did differently was to omit the olives, since I don't like them. Also I used a yellow pepper in place of the green, as green peppers don't like me. I used 1/2 cup of mayonnaise in the beginning with all the spices. I served mine with toasted and buttered ciabatta bread. Heaven! My husband thought it was a winner too. Try it, you'll like it!



Find More Recipes