Flemming's Steakhouse Scalloped Potatoes

Flemming's Steakhouse Scalloped Potatoes created by NcMysteryShopper

Flemmings Steakhouse and Wine Bar is noted for it's perfectly cooked prime beef. I would go there just for the potatoes and wine selection. If you like hot you can add more jalapeno.

Ready In:
1hr 20mins



  • Preheat oven to 350°F.
  • Spray bottom and sides of a 9x12 inch baking dish with non-stick cooking spray.
  • Place cream, half-and-half, salt and pepper in a heavy sauce pan and bring to a simmer over medium high heat.
  • Place jalapeno, leeks and cheese in a large mixing bowl, add cream and mix thoroughly.
  • Add potatoes and mix.
  • Spread potato mixture evenly in prepared baking dish, cover tightly with foil and bake 45 minutes.
  • Remove foil and bake 15 minutes or until browned and potatoes are tender.
Submit a Recipe Correction


Add a Note
Enter The Sweepstakes


"Flemmings Steakhouse and Wine Bar is noted for it's perfectly cooked prime beef. I would go there just for the potatoes and wine selection. If you like hot you can add more jalapeno."

Join The Conversation

sort by:
  1. Jack B.
    The trick is to prep your potatoes first rinse them a couple of times and let sit in cold water for about 15 minutes. As you get your other ingredients ready bring a pot of water to a complete boil and add potatoes for about 10 minutes. Drain and continue with the cooking procedure this helps in so many ways. Creamier sauce faster cook time and softer potatoes make sure you cover pan first with foil and end with broiling it to brown. A little paprika or cayenne pepper gives it a very nice kick also. Enjoy !<br/><br/> J. B.
  2. Judgejilly
    Im only putting four stars because I made a lot of changes to this recipe. I used 5 medium-sized russet potatoes and cut them into 1/8 of an inch pieces. I simmered the heavy cream, half and half, salt, black pepper, 1 tsp onion powder and about 1/3 cup chopped jarred jalepenos. When it got warm enough, I stirred (in increments) two cups of white sharp shredded cheddar into the sauce. I layered potatoes in my greased 9X13 pan, and poured about 1/2 a cup of sauce and spread to coat each layer. I ended up with about five layers. I reserved the last cup of cheddar to spread over the top. Also, didn't cover it with foil because I felt it needed to thicken and evaporate out a bit.<br/><br/>The end result was FANTASTIC. Hubby ate half of the pan himself. Will definitely make these potatoes again!!!!
  3. Sauce Lover
    I used two jalapenos instead of one and it had just the right bite to it, not too spicy at all. These turned out really good but I think next time I would use less potatoes so that I have a creamier version. The best scalloped potatoes I've ever made or ever had!! A must try to everyone out there!!!! I have made this several times and I too find it easier to put the shredded cheese directly into the heavy cream, half and half mixture and then it melts down evenly. I usually use 3lbs of potatoes instead of 4lbs and that way they turn out cheesier and creamier. Had to increase the cooking time also, might just be my oven. Delicious!!
  4. mststime1204
    These potatoes were awesome! WIth some "minor" adjustments. When I warmed the half and half & heavy cream, I added the shredded cheddar cheese and made a sauce. In addition, I added some butter. (taste vs calories) I cut my russet potatoes thin, but still added about a 1/2 hour cooking time.
  5. Mary N.
    These were ok, but not the best potatoes I've ever had. I followed the recipe exactly. First of all, my potatoes took twice as long to cook. For a total time of 2 1/2 hours and I sliced the potatoes super thin, a lot thinner than 1/4 inch. The flavor was good, but I did not like how the cream mixture turned kind of clumpy while it cooked and not smooth. I believe this is from just warming up the cream and half and half and not making a roux to stabilize the mixture and keep it from not separating. The jalapeno gave the dish a good flavor and was not too hot at all. However, I will keep looking for "the" recipe as I like my scalloped potato cheese sauce to be creamy and not separated. But thanks for posting, I see a lot of people like this dish a lot. So it just must be my picky preference!

Find More Recipes