Crustless Pumpkin Pie Custard

"I haven't made this but my step mother makes it all the time. It is a very good pie."
photo by BeccaB3c photo by BeccaB3c
photo by BeccaB3c
Ready In:




  • Beat eggs and mix in bowl with remaining ingredients.
  • Pour into a glass pie pan and bake in a 350 oven for 50 minutes or until set in the middle.

Questions & Replies

default avatar
Got a question? Share it with the community!


  1. Cathie in Florida
    Great recipe. Changes I made were for special dietary reasons: Better'n Eggs instead of eggs and Splenda instead of sugar. All else in the recipe were the same and it was DELICIOUS. Thanks for sharing this recipe. KCATHIE
  2. its_me_susan
    Good & easy to make (I let my 2 & 4 year old help make this)! I reduced the sugar to 1/3rd cup, and we used Readi-Whip on top. A good way to get pumpkin in young children!
  3. amy.cleaveland
    I love the idea of crustless pumpkin pie, but this one seemed watery and granular. I might switch back to evaporated milk (and maybe switch brands of pumpkin) to make a smoother consistency. Also, I'd probably use just 1/4t of nutmeg next time since the flavor was overpowering. I enjoyed it overall, but my husband couldn't eat more than a bite.
  4. Elaine
    This hits the spot. I love anty thing pumpkin! I used Egg Beaters and Sugar Twin suger substitute and light soy milk and it turned out great. I also sometimes use Special Pumpkin Pie Seasoning for Hillvilla Pumpkin Pie Recipe #2174172 when I want a change. Excellent Recipe, thanks for posting!
  5. lea_petra
    Thanks for a low sodium pumpkin pie, that is just as good as one with a crust. That was one dessert my husband thought he was going to miss out on. I was worried that it was going to come out like a pudding, not like a pie, but it held it's shape very well.


I live in Western KS and am a K-5 Librarian. I love to cook! Don't we all? I'm married to a VERY picky eater. For me, cooking is a great way to relax. I love baking the best. Christmas is my favorite time of year because I can make so many yummy goodies. I'd like to make goodies year-round but we definitely don't need it!
View Full Profile

Find More Recipes