Crazy Good Crock Pot Chicke Tortilla Soup

"There was a little restaurant in Lewis Center, OH called Nacho Mama's that had the best chicken tortilla soup I ever tasted. When it went out of business, I had to find out how to reproduce it - once I did, I slowly improved on the recipe until I made it my own."
photo by Columbus Foodie photo by Columbus Foodie
photo by Columbus Foodie
Ready In:
8hrs 20mins




  • Empty the the taco seasoning packets into a plastic bag, and place the chicken in the bag and shake to coat the chicken with the taco seasoning.
  • On a contact grill, grill the chicken until fully cooked, about 7 minutes.
  • While the chicken is grilling, saute the onion and garlic in a pan with the olive oil, until softened.
  • Sliced the chicken into 1/2 inch slices and place it into the crock pot along with the onions and garlic.
  • Place the following ingredients in the crock pot in this order: chicken broth, tomatoes, corn, and lime juice.
  • Add cumin, salt, and chili powder to taste. Experiment with what your preferences are, being sure to remember that the flavor will deepen and intensify as the soup cooks. In other words, the final result will be stronger, so go light on the seasonings if you don't like it spicy.
  • Cook on high for about 6-8 hours, or low for 10-12 hours.
  • To assemble the final product, in a shallow bowl, place tortilla strips on the bottom, and then spoon the soup over top. Finish with your choice of garnish, all are recommended for the best taste.

Questions & Replies

  1. How do you add ingredients to your grocery list from a recipe?


  1. I went and bought all the ingredients not realizing this is not really a slow cooker recipe but a grill for a few hours then slow cook recipe. This is not apartment friendly. This should not be under the slow cooker recipes at all.
  2. You don't need to grill the chicken. Just toss it in the crock pot and then shred it after a few hours. Also, I added celery and garbonzo beans. Awesome taste!
  3. Wow.... AMAZING recipe. Yes, having to grill the chicken in taco seasoning does add an extra step, but the flavor of the grill and seasoning on the chicken is what makes this recipe extra delicious. I didn't have ready-made taco seasoning on hand, so used "Kintencals" on here. Yum yum yum! <br/><br/>Oh, I think adding some black beans would have made it just a touch heartier for my husband who thinks of soup as a starter, not a main dish.
  4. Excellent recipe... Easy, but VERY tasty. Great ideas in here, I added a few extra peppers for some heat. Worked great, easy to build on this recipe. Love the avocado on top!
  5. My Brother-in-law loves to Cook! I tried this amazing soup! WOW! It hit the spot just my husband wants me to make it for him. The fresh tortilla strips is the key to this recipe! Yummy!


I'm a thirtysomething woman from Columbus, Ohio who has been married to my wonderful husband Paul for 10 years. I love to cook and take pictures, and have a food blog called Columbus Foodie at <br> <br>I'm a recent college graduate, and currently don't work outside of the home. For fun, I enter sweepstakes, garden, read, craft and scrapbook, and watch bad TV. <br> <br><img src=>
View Full Profile

Find More Recipes