Creamy New York Strip Stew

"Nice, creamy, and tender stew that is extremely filling and comforting."
photo by teresas photo by teresas
photo by teresas
Ready In:
2hrs 15mins




  • Put flour, salt, and pepper in large ziploc bag.
  • Heat oil over medium heat in a deep skillet.
  • Place meat in bag with flour and toss until coated.
  • Shake off pieces and add to skillet and cook until browned.
  • Add remaining flour and onions and stir until browned.
  • Add carrots, celery, parsley, and broth.
  • Cover and cook over low_medium heat for 1 hour stirring every 5-10 minutes.
  • Add potatoes and additional carrots and cook for another 30-45 minutes until potatoes are fork tender.
  • OPTIONAL- during the last 5 minutes add a drained can of corn.

Questions & Replies

  1. Why would your recipe call for diced potatoes and your picture shows large potato chunks and mushrooms? I think you should have a picture of what you are making.


  1. This stew is just delicious. Very hearty and creamy, and full of flavor. I mixed in some frozen peas at the end instead of corn, and instead of salt I seasoned it with Maggi seasoning, which gave it a nice umami flavor. The meat came out super-tender as well, so this recipe is a real keeper.
  2. This stew is so very yummy and first I didn't want to babysit my stew...but I grabbed a book and enjoyed my timer going off every 5 mins...I did that for the 1st half hour the last half I set the timer for every 10 really do need to make sure you scrape up all the good stuff on the bottom of the pot...btw...I used a wide bottom pot so the meat would brown nice and crispy...which it meat did absorb all the oil so when I put in the rest of the flour and the turned to didn't want to I just went to step 6 and the next thing I knew I had this nice thick creamy tasty stuff...I cut my potatoes in chunks and they were perfect after cooking for 45 mins...I still scraped up the bits and pieces off the bottom of the pot...I had some mushrooms that needed to be used up so I threw them in for the last 10 mins...I decided against the corn...althou the corn would have given it a nice additional color...and probably flavor...I did add some extra salt and pepper...Oh! almost forgot...the meat turned out so tender...thanks for posting's a keeper =)



Find More Recipes