Butternut Squash Pasta Sauce

"I have not tried this recipe. I got it from Health Matters newspaper. This recipe makes about 4 cups of sauce. That's enough for 3 pounds of cheese ravioli or 1 1/2 pounds (8 servings) of short pasta, such as penne or ziti."
photo by Lalaloula photo by Lalaloula
photo by Lalaloula
photo by InkysChef photo by InkysChef
Ready In:
1hr 20mins




  • Preheat oven to 375. Using a large, sharp knife,trim the squash ends, then halve the squash crosswise to separate the bulb from the neck. Peel with a vegetable peeler. Cut both pieces in half lengthwise. With a spoon, scoop out seeds; discard.
  • Cut squash into 2-inch chunks. Transfer to a small rimmed baking sheet. Toss with oil and sage. Season generously with salt and pepper. Scatter garlic around squash. Roast until squash is very tender, about 40 minutes, tossing once halfway through. Remove and discard skin from garlic.
  • Tansfer squash and garlic to a food processor. Puree. With motor running, add half and half through the feed tube; process until smooth. Add 1 to 2 cups water. Continue to process until smooth, adding water to thin if necessary. Season again generously with salt. (To freeze, see below).
  • Cook pasta according to package instructions. Reserve 1 cup pasta water. Drain pasta and return to pot. Pour sauce over pasta; toss to coat. Add some pasta water to thin sauce if necessary. Serve with desired toppings. Once you've tossed the pasta with the sauce, serve it topped with any or all of the following: Toasted Walnuts, additional parmesan cheese, Torn fresh sage leaves.
  • To Freeze: Cool sauce to room temperature to airtight containers, leaving 1 inch of space. Freeze up to 3 months. When ready to use, place plastic containers upside down under hot tap water to help release frozen blocks of sauce. Place blocks in a large saucepan. Cover and reheat over medium-low,adding water to thin if necessary.
  • (To serve with pasta,see step 4).

Questions & Replies

default avatar
Got a question? Share it with the community!


  1. sconehead
    This was GREAT!! I used an acorn squash that I had already cooked. I used about 2 cups puree and added the spices, garlic and a can of evaporated skim milk. I used my hand blender to blend all to gether and make it smooth. I also added 1/4 cup grated parm. cheese to melt. Then I served it over penne pasta. My kids LOVED it and LOVED that it was healthy and full of vitamins and they didn't even know it!
  2. InkysChef
    This was great! I made it for a debate watch party last night and served it over cheese ravioli, alongside soime autumn beers. The preparation is simple and the result is delicious. I found that it needed a bit more sage and quite a bit of salt and pepper when I was heating it on the stove after pureeing. Also, I topped it with some chopped fresh basil, which was excellent. This is a great way to use squash and I will make it again. Thanks for posting!
  3. Nanners
    I have been making this exact recipe for my family for about a year (I found it in Everyday Food magazine), and they all love it. My son, who hates all vegetables, doesn't even realize he's eating squash - thinks it's a cheese sauce because it's so flavorful and rich. It is especially divine over portabello mushroom ravioli. My husband says this dish is something you'd find in a gourmet Italian restaurant. I guess it freezes well, but I wouldn't know because it never makes it to the freezer in our house!!
  4. Trish B.
    The hardest part was cutting the butternut squash. After I added the Half & Half, I loved the consistency, so I didn’t add any water. Used fresh small ravioli. My husband said I can make this any time!
  5. allforless
    I loved it. Of course I tweaked it. After baking it an extra 30 minutes I threw it in my Ninja and added nutmeg and cinnamon (to taste) with a pinch of salt. I used a full can of condensed milk added about 1/3 water to the can( to get every bit of milk out!) Then pureed and thinned it out with chicken broth. We loved it. It easily made enough sauce for 6 people. We had 3 so I froze the rest for another night.


  1. carlamoose
    I liked this sauce a lot more than I thought I would. I improvised because I had a little bit of heavy cream to use, but not 1/2 cup. Then I poured in milk until desired consistency. I used Italian seasoning instead of sage.
  2. Lalaloula
    Wow, that was yummy! ;) The only change I made was to use fresh sage (2 sprigs) and broth and milk instead of half-and-half and water. Thanks for sharing! I'll definitely make this soon again. Perhaps I'll also try to turn it into a casserole by sprinkling it with cheese and baking it in the oven.


<p>Square Meals Make Round People - Author Unknown <br /><br />Do It With Love---It Will Taste Better - Author Unknown <br /><br />I joined zaar in 2002 but I really didn't use it much on until 2006 after my computer crashed and I lost all my unsaved recipes. Now I post all recipes I've tried or would like to try. I'm actually making it my goal to try almost all the recipes I've posted as soon as I can. I love food and I love to eat and try different recipes. My favorite course is dessert. I love sweets! This leads me to that I did have Gastric Bypass surgery on July 25th 2008. On that note I love baking and cooking a priceless gift passed down from my grammy who I dearly loved and miss deeply. My grammy passed away 1/15/07. She was a wonderful cook and baker and taught me many things and the most valueable things was how to be a wonderful cook and baker like her. I really enjoy searching for new recipes especially here on Zaar. I'm always finding and adding to my cookbook new and exciting recipes. I also enjoy posting recipes here on Zaar as well. I really love collecting different cookbooks. I have over a 100 and growing! I collect mostly Taste Of Home &amp; community cookbooks. The minute I get a cookbook home I sit down and I read my cookbooks from front to back like novels. I work for the Elmira City School&nbsp;District and YWCA. I'm raising my&nbsp;8 yrs old newphew. I'm a part time college student studing Early Childhood Education, but taking time off and hoping to return soon. I live in Elmira, New York where famous writer Mark Twain did some of his writing and he once lived. I have&nbsp;1 cats Samantha and&nbsp;1 dog our newest member MOO MOO (my nieces dog) who are my children as I do not have any human children of my own. I lost&nbsp;four of my very dear children (kitty's) Callie June 2007, Miss Kitty in March 2010, my dog Angel in December 2010, and my other cat Chase in September&nbsp;2011. I'm recently&nbsp;married on August 12th 2010. I love spending time with my niece&nbsp;9 yrs old and my newphews&nbsp;7 &amp;&nbsp;8 yrs old. I enjoy couponing and trading coupons. I love the internet as there's so much to look at online even though you know where I spend most of my time! I enjoy going to yard sales and estate sales every spring - fall. I love gardening and have many different pretty flowers.</p> 8724441"
View Full Profile

Find More Recipes