Blue Heaven Banana Pancakes

"This is my version of the banana pancakes from Blue Heaven in Key West, FL. I've eaten there so many times and miss their delicious pancakes. It's not their exact recipe, obviously, but I think I got the flavor and texture almost exactly right!"
photo by Tropical Texan photo by Tropical Texan
photo by Tropical Texan
Ready In:
8 4-5




  • Beat egg until fluffy. Add milk and oil/melted butter. Add vanilla.
  • In another bowl, combine all dry ingredients.
  • Take bananas out of skin and cut into very small pieces (1/2"). They do not have to be perfect, and do not worry about then getting a bit "mashed".
  • Add dry ingredients gradually to egg mixture.
  • Add cut bananas (and toasted nuts, optional).
  • In a non-stick 8-10" skillet, heat pan to medium. Pan is ready when water dances on surface.
  • Pour batter in pan using ladle or pitcher, forming a pancake approx 4-5" wide.
  • When the edges start looking a little "matte" and the pancake is bubbly, flip. When you see steam start "wisping" from the edges of the pancake, it is done.
  • Top with syrup (mix ingredients above and heat in microwave for 30-45 seconds), whipped cream, or more bananas and nuts.

Questions & Replies

default avatar
Got a question? Share it with the community!


  1. Juliansmommy
    These are the best banana pancakes from scratch I have ever had. Way better than any box mix. I like simple so I didn't add any spices and used plane old maple syrup. My whole family loves them.
  2. Slatts
    I am pretty finicky when it comes to pancake recipes and these are fantastic. We made them exactly as stated but used half regular flour and half wheat flour. DH, who isn't a banana pancake fan in general, liked them a lot. Not a low cal everyday treat but definate must for special occasions. Yum!!!
  3. Pixies Kitchen
    I made these yesterday morning with some bananas that were on their way out and these were amazing, I made the syrup as well and I can't wait to try the syrup on waffles and pancakes since we had some leftover. The kids devoured these and we put a little bit of some homemade whip cream on them as well. They are easy enough to make and are quick to the table. Thank you for posting such a great recipe!
  4. Sydney Mike
    Have never been to the Key West restaurant, but I can tell you ~ These pancakes are GREAT! Loved the addition of spices & nuts, & the syrup part of the recipe, well, you can bottle that & peddle it in my area for sure! Thanks for such a GREAT TASTE TREAT! [Made & reviewed for one of my adopted chefs in this Spring's PAC]



Find More Recipes