21 Copycat Desserts

Our members have cracked the recipe code to some of America's most beloved sweets, including Krispy Kremes, Thin Mint Girl Scout cookies and Twinkies.

Mrs. Fields' Chocolate Chip Cookies

"These are absolutely the best chocolate chip cookies I have ever made, and that's saying something! I've already started thinking up all kinds of wonderful variations."


Skor Bars

"These taste just like Skor bars! They're great — and very addictive."


Ferrero Rochers

"Who doesn't love these rich, chocolate-hazelnut balls? Crunchy wafers and buttery ground nuts are bound together with Nutella and wrapped around a whole hazelnut for a decadent treat you can make any day."


Girl Scout Samoa Cookies

"These cookies are fantastic. My fiancee and I think that they're actually better than the originals."


PayDay Bars

"Yum! These bars are absolutely delicious, and so quick and easy to make! Loved the salty and sweet combination!"


See's Fudge

"I don't usually like fudge because of it's crumbly consistency, but this was wonderful and creamy."


Hostess Cupcakes

This amazing recipe is a homemade take on America's favorite chocolate cupcake. You won't be able to taste the difference!

Hostess Twinkies

The only thing better than Twinkies? Twinkies from scratch! Your friends and family will beg for more (and more!) of these cakes.

Krispy Kreme Doughnuts

"These doughnuts are amazing, and they taste very similar to Krispy Kremes! For the best results, be sure to keep a close eye on the temperature as they cook."

-Pink Frosting

Betty Crocker Boxed Brownies

"These brownies were really good. I love that I can mix the dry ingredients and store them for later."


Costco Muffins

"What a great recipe! I did the chocolate muffins and the lemon blueberry muffins and everyone in my house loved them."


Gummy Worms

"I love gummy worms! These make a nice snack when you want something sweet. They taste like the real thing — only better!"

-Miss Annie in Indy

Cinnabon Rolls With Icing

"I've made these babies twice already and believe me — they are so, so good! They taste just like Cinnabon. Plus, the dough is a breeze to work with."


Cadbury Creme Eggs

"Awesome! These taste just like Cadbury Creme Eggs! I used a plastic egg mold to make them easier to form. Simple, fun and delicious!"


Girl Scout Thin Mints

"Absolutely delish! I used one a 1/2 teaspoon peppermint extract instead of peppermint oil. We eat these right out of the freezer!"

-Sky Hostess


"These were excellent. They tasted exactly like the Drumstick cones."

-Marie Nixon

Nabisco's Old Fashioned Gingersnaps

"The perfect gingersnap! This recipe was very easy to make, and its blend of spices is wonderful. All I could say about the finished product was mmm!"

-Denyse 1966

Fig Newtons

Sweet — but not too sweet! — these soft fig roll cookies are dead ringers for Fig Newtons!

Oh Henry! Bars

"This candy was so insanely good that I immediately gave most of it away so I wouldn't eat the whole pan!"


Peanut Butter Cups

"WOW! These are fantastic. I love the simple ingredients, and how quick this comes together. With semi-sweet chocolate on top, these are very rich and delicious."


Dairy Queen Blizzards

"This is a really fun recipe. Everyone got to pick their own candy to put in the shake and they all tasted so good."

-Flowers and Pearls