I try to be fair when reviewing a recipe. If I suspect a fault, confusion or just plain stupidity on my side I will say so in my review. 5 Stars: Very good - a keeper! 4 Stars: Very good, and I will make it again. 3 Stars: Edible/Good, but lacked something and I definately won't make it again. 2 Stars: Tasteless and not worth the effort. 1 Star: Inedible and a waste of good ingredients.