I'm looking for:
  • Start Here
    • Course
    • Main Ingredient
    • Cuisine
    • Preparation
    • Occasion
    • Diet
    • Nutrition
1

Select () or exclude () categories to narrow your recipe search.

2

As you select categories, the number of matching recipes will update.

Make some selections to begin narrowing your results.
  • Calories
  • Amount per serving
    1. Total Fat
    2. Saturated Fat
    3. Polyunsat. Fat
    4. Monounsat. Fat
    5. Trans Fat
  • Cholesterol
  • Sodium
  • Potassium
  • Total Carbohydrates
    1. Dietary Fiber
    2. Sugars
  • Protein
  • Vitamin A
  • Vitamin B6
  • Vitamin B12
  • Vitamin C
  • Calcium
  • Iron
  • Vitamin E
  • Magnesium
  • Alcohol
  • Caffeine

    • Find exactly what you're looking for with the web's most powerful recipe filtering tool.

    You are in: Home / Cuisine / North American / American / Northeastern / Amish/Mennonite
    Lost? Site Map

    Amish/Mennonite Recipes

    From Macaroni Salad to Amish Bread, our members' favorite Amish and Mennonite recipes offer highlights of this cuisine.

    Add Your Recipes

    Newest Amish Mennonite Recipes

    Recipe #479264

    Shoo-Fly Pie
    Handle

    Select One

    A great winter pie from an Amish furniture store flyer, submitted to them by an Amish quilter. It's all carbs, but yummy. Some people like to increase...

    Shoo-Fly Pie

    By alvinakatz on May 12, 2012

    Recipe #479264

    Add to Cookbook Add to Menu

    "A great winter pie from an Amish furniture store flyer, submitted to them by an Amish quilter. It's all carbs, but yummy. Some people like to increase the quantity of the crumb mixture to make a deeper topping."

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: dark brown sugar, eggs...

    Be the first to review!

    Prep Time:15 mins

    Total Time: 1 hrs

    Recipe #472340

    Stewed Cheese
    Handle

    Select One

    Another Depression meal handed down. This along with Pop's Hamburger and Beans are meals we had as kids when EVERYBODY went to my Great Grandmother's...

    Stewed Cheese

    By Xavier&Logan on January 18, 2012

    Recipe #472340

    Add to Cookbook Add to Menu

    "Another Depression meal handed down. This along with Pop's Hamburger and Beans are meals we had as kids when EVERYBODY went to my Great Grandmother's house down the shore. It is VERY easy to make, VERY easy to stretch and VERY Good! It is a meal that does NOT look appetizing, but once you eat it you won't be able to stop. MOST people (oustside our..."

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: onions, water, bread...

    Be the first to review!

    Prep Time:15 mins

    Total Time: 45 mins

    Pocono Style Apple Dumplings
    Handle

    Select One

    Pennsylvania Dutch style Apple Dumplings.

    This recipe is my own creation after trying apple dumplings for the first time on a trip to the Poconos...

    Pocono Style Apple Dumplings

    Recipe #467500

    Pocono Style Apple Dumplings

    By Lostfairy on November 5, 2011

    Recipe #467500

    Add to Cookbook Add to Menu

    "Pennsylvania Dutch style Apple Dumplings. This recipe is my own creation after trying apple dumplings for the first time on a trip to the Poconos to pick pumpkins. They were a special on the menu at a small diner in Saylorsburg - I had never tasted anything quite so delicious. The dough is soft and almost uncooked at the bottom, the pastry soaked..."

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: cinnamon, eggs, milk...

    Be the first to review!

    Prep Time:30 mins

    Total Time: 1 hrs

    Recipe #467423

    Amish Country Casserole
    Handle

    Select One

    This is a warm comforting recipe that has been passed down through the Amish community

    Amish Country Casserole

    By GingerlyJ on November 4, 2011

    Recipe #467423

    Add to Cookbook Add to Menu

    "This is a warm comforting recipe that has been passed down through the Amish community"

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: condensed tomato soup, milk...

    1 Reviews

    Prep Time:10 mins

    Total Time: 45 mins

    Delicous Dutch Baby
    Handle

    Select One

    Light, fluffy, and delicous. Great for weekend mornings. Really easy to make and will please the whole family.

    Delicous Dutch Baby

    Recipe #458220

    Delicous Dutch Baby

    By debiasio1089 on June 7, 2011

    Recipe #458220

    Add to Cookbook Add to Menu

    "Light, fluffy, and delicous. Great for weekend mornings. Really easy to make and will please the whole family."

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: eggs, margarine, milk...

    3 Reviews

    Prep Time:10 mins

    Total Time: 22 mins

    Recipe #458129

    Chicken 'n' Summer Squash over Mashed Potatoes
    Handle

    Select One

    A popular country-style dish in Ohio is chicken 'n' noodles over mashed potatoes. They serve this a lot at Amish restaurants, but I don't...

    Chicken 'n' Summer Squash over Mashed Potatoes

    By MistyCat82 on June 6, 2011

    Recipe #458129

    Add to Cookbook Add to Menu

    "A popular country-style dish in Ohio is chicken 'n' noodles over mashed potatoes. They serve this a lot at Amish restaurants, but I don't know if it is specifically Amish. Yes, we love our starches. =D I have tried to make it more healthful by substituting sliced summer squash in place of the noodles. I also cook it in a slow cooker so it is fairly..."

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: mirepoix, milk, onions...

    Be the first to review!

    Prep Time:30 mins

    Total Time: 8 hrs 30 mins

    Recipe #457655

    Chicken Corn Soup
    Handle

    Select One

    1970'S recipe from The Family Style Restaurant in Lancaster, PA

    Chicken Corn Soup

    By Chef #837406 on May 31, 2011

    Recipe #457655

    Add to Cookbook Add to Menu

    "1970'S recipe from The Family Style Restaurant in Lancaster, PA"

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: cream of celery soup, creamed corn...

    Be the first to review!

    Prep Time:15 mins

    Total Time: 2 hrs 45 mins

    Recipe #453923

    Amish/ Mennonite Spam and Macaroni Casserole
    Handle

    Select One

    I got this from an Amish/ mennonite cookbook, it is one of the only recipes I can stand spam in

    Amish/ Mennonite Spam and Macaroni Casserole

    By GingerlyJ on April 18, 2011

    Recipe #453923

    Add to Cookbook Add to Menu

    "I got this from an Amish/ mennonite cookbook, it is one of the only recipes I can stand spam in"

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: pepper, elbow macaroni...

    Be the first to review!

    Prep Time:15 mins

    Total Time: 1 hrs

    Recipe #453821

    Farmouse Icebox Pickles
    Handle

    Select One

    My friend Cecily and her family make these pickles to sell at the farmer's market. they are quick and easy but amazing

    Farmouse Icebox Pickles

    By GingerlyJ on April 16, 2011

    Recipe #453821

    Add to Cookbook Add to Menu

    "My friend Cecily and her family make these pickles to sell at the farmer's market. they are quick and easy but amazing"

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: cucumbers, dry mustard, onions...

    Be the first to review!

    Prep Time:10 mins

    Total Time: 240 hrs 10 mins

    Recipe #453680

    Cecily's Amish Asparagus in a Bacon-Cheese Sauce
    Handle

    Select One

    My Amish friend Cecily is a wonderful cook. she grows her own asparagus and makes this often in the springtime

    Cecily's Amish Asparagus in a Bacon-Cheese Sauce

    By GingerlyJ on April 13, 2011

    Recipe #453680

    Add to Cookbook Add to Menu

    "My Amish friend Cecily is a wonderful cook. she grows her own asparagus and makes this often in the springtime"

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: milk, sea salt...

    Be the first to review!

    Prep Time:15 mins

    Total Time: 20 mins

    Recipe #450800

    Kayley's Addictive Frosted Sugar Cookies
    Handle

    Select One

    Mmmmmm! Rock your someone special's world with these delicious rolled sugar cookies. They have just the perfect amount of softness, sweetness...

    Kayley's Addictive Frosted Sugar Cookies

    By Lois on March 14, 2011

    Recipe #450800

    Add to Cookbook Add to Menu

    "Mmmmmm! Rock your someone special's world with these delicious rolled sugar cookies. They have just the perfect amount of softness, sweetness and yumminess. Please be sure not to roll them too thin or overbake them, which will make them too crisp."

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: cream of tartar, eggs...

    Be the first to review!

    Prep Time:2 hrs

    Total Time: 2 hrs 9 mins

    Recipe #443373

    Amish Shoofly Pie
    Handle

    Select One

    Do you love old fashioned pies ,you know,the kind people have almost forgotten about because they don't come ready in the frozen food section?Do you...

    Amish Shoofly Pie

    By Chef #928625 on December 1, 2010

    Recipe #443373

    Add to Cookbook Add to Menu

    "Do you love old fashioned pies ,you know,the kind people have almost forgotten about because they don't come ready in the frozen food section?Do you love dark,gooey super sweet deserts?Do you love molasses?Do you eat it by the spoonful?(So maybe you don't eat it by the spoonful..that's just me)If you do this is the ULTIMATE pie.There's nothing to get..."

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: dark brown sugar, dark molasses...

    Be the first to review!

    Prep Time:10 mins

    Total Time: 55 mins

    « Previous  123...1920Next »
    Displaying up to 20 pages of results.

    Advertisement

    Newest Reviews for Amish/Mennonite Recipes

    Frito Lay Bean Dip

     59 Reviews

    "I think this recipe has a lot of potential. I should have re-read all of the feedback before beginning... my dip tasted tooo salty, and I generally am..." more 

    By Gidget265
    on 0

    Yummy Crunchy Caramel Apple Pie

     389 Reviews

    "My daughter made this for me for Mother's Day by my request. I have had this recipe saved in my "Want to Try" cookbook for a long time and was waiting..." more 

    By Chris from Kansas
    on 0

    Meatball Supper Soup

     13 Reviews

    "I made it pretty much as directed, except I left the bread crumbs out of the meatballs - to make them closer to a "primal or paleo" recipe. I took it to..." more 

    By thejonesgal
    on 0

    Photos

    Browse All Photos

    More Ideas from Food.com

    Cheeseburger

    Summer Central

    We've collected our best grilled recipes, pasta salads, fruit desserts and more.

    Advertisement

    Over 400,000 Recipes

    Food.com Network of Sites