I'm looking for:
  • Start Here
    • Course
    • Main Ingredient
    • Cuisine
    • Preparation
    • Occasion
    • Diet
    • Nutrition
1

Select () or exclude () categories to narrow your recipe search.

2

As you select categories, the number of matching recipes will update.

Make some selections to begin narrowing your results.
  • Calories
  • Amount per serving
    1. Total Fat
    2. Saturated Fat
    3. Polyunsat. Fat
    4. Monounsat. Fat
    5. Trans Fat
  • Cholesterol
  • Sodium
  • Potassium
  • Total Carbohydrates
    1. Dietary Fiber
    2. Sugars
  • Protein
  • Vitamin A
  • Vitamin B6
  • Vitamin B12
  • Vitamin C
  • Calcium
  • Iron
  • Vitamin E
  • Magnesium
  • Alcohol
  • Caffeine

    • Find exactly what you're looking for with the web's most powerful recipe filtering tool.

    You are in: Home / Cuisine / North American / American / Northeastern / Amish/Mennonite / Amish/Mennonite Comfort Food
    Lost? Site Map

    Amish/Mennonite Comfort Food Recipes

    Add Your Recipes

    Newest Amish Mennonite Comfort Food Recipes

    Recipe #467423

    Amish Country Casserole
    Handle

    Select One

    This is a warm comforting recipe that has been passed down through the Amish community

    Amish Country Casserole

    By GingerlyJ on November 4, 2011

    Recipe #467423

    Add to Cookbook Add to Menu

    "This is a warm comforting recipe that has been passed down through the Amish community"

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: condensed tomato soup, milk...

    1 Reviews

    Prep Time:10 mins

    Total Time: 45 mins

    Recipe #458129

    Chicken 'n' Summer Squash over Mashed Potatoes
    Handle

    Select One

    A popular country-style dish in Ohio is chicken 'n' noodles over mashed potatoes. They serve this a lot at Amish restaurants, but I don't...

    Chicken 'n' Summer Squash over Mashed Potatoes

    By MistyCat82 on June 6, 2011

    Recipe #458129

    Add to Cookbook Add to Menu

    "A popular country-style dish in Ohio is chicken 'n' noodles over mashed potatoes. They serve this a lot at Amish restaurants, but I don't know if it is specifically Amish. Yes, we love our starches. =D I have tried to make it more healthful by substituting sliced summer squash in place of the noodles. I also cook it in a slow cooker so it is fairly..."

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: mirepoix, milk, onions...

    Be the first to review!

    Prep Time:30 mins

    Total Time: 8 hrs 30 mins

    Recipe #457655

    Chicken Corn Soup
    Handle

    Select One

    1970'S recipe from The Family Style Restaurant in Lancaster, PA

    Chicken Corn Soup

    By Chef #837406 on May 31, 2011

    Recipe #457655

    Add to Cookbook Add to Menu

    "1970'S recipe from The Family Style Restaurant in Lancaster, PA"

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: cream of celery soup, creamed corn...

    Be the first to review!

    Prep Time:15 mins

    Total Time: 2 hrs 45 mins

    Recipe #453923

    Amish/ Mennonite Spam and Macaroni Casserole
    Handle

    Select One

    I got this from an Amish/ mennonite cookbook, it is one of the only recipes I can stand spam in

    Amish/ Mennonite Spam and Macaroni Casserole

    By GingerlyJ on April 18, 2011

    Recipe #453923

    Add to Cookbook Add to Menu

    "I got this from an Amish/ mennonite cookbook, it is one of the only recipes I can stand spam in"

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: pepper, elbow macaroni...

    Be the first to review!

    Prep Time:15 mins

    Total Time: 1 hrs

    Recipe #437027

    Amish Peanut Butter
    Handle

    Select One

    This is a very tasty peanut butter spread that is often served at Amish restaurants. It is common within Mennonite communities and is sometimes known as...

    Amish Peanut Butter

    By Alan in SW Florida on September 10, 2010

    Recipe #437027

    Add to Cookbook Add to Menu

    "This is a very tasty peanut butter spread that is often served at Amish restaurants. It is common within Mennonite communities and is sometimes known as "church spread", since it is brought and served at their church gatherings. It is great on bread, bananas, ice cream, graham crackers, ect. Kids, of all ages, will love this!!! ;)"

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: creamy peanut butter, warm water...

    Be the first to review!

    Prep Time:20 mins

    Total Time: 20 mins

    Recipe #376633

    Amish Butter Noodles 1965
    Handle

    Select One

    I had these while I was having a buffet in Shipshewana, asked for the recipe for the noodles, and here it is.

    Amish Butter Noodles 1965

    By andypandy on June 10, 2009

    Recipe #376633

    Add to Cookbook Add to Menu

    "I had these while I was having a buffet in Shipshewana, asked for the recipe for the noodles, and here it is."

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: eggs, milk, salt...

    1 Reviews

    Prep Time:30 mins

    Total Time: 35 mins

    Amish Bean Soup
    Handle

    Select One

    This is a wonderful warm soup to warm the heart in these last cold days of winter. Being in Wisconsin, warm soup is always a welcome thing. This is a...

    Amish Bean Soup

    Recipe #358385

    Amish Bean Soup

    By LilPinkieJ on March 1, 2009

    Recipe #358385

    Add to Cookbook Add to Menu

    "This is a wonderful warm soup to warm the heart in these last cold days of winter. Being in Wisconsin, warm soup is always a welcome thing. This is a very simple amish soup, so it has very simple ingredients. It's perfect for a beginner cook or someone like me who just wants something easy."

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: ham bone, onions...

    3 Reviews

    Prep Time:1 hrs

    Total Time: 4 hrs

    Recipe #353235

    White Chocolate Oreo Cream Cheese Balls
    Handle

    Select One

    I think this recipe is very good it is also very simple. It came from one of my girlfriends. A tip is to swirl the oreo balls in the white chocolate and...

    White Chocolate Oreo Cream Cheese Balls

    By Chef #1152631 on January 31, 2009

    Recipe #353235

    Add to Cookbook Add to Menu

    "I think this recipe is very good it is also very simple. It came from one of my girlfriends. A tip is to swirl the oreo balls in the white chocolate and not dunk them in. You could also use milk chocolate instead of white."

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: cream cheese, Oreo cookies...

    2 Reviews

    Prep Time:20 mins

    Total Time: 40 mins

    Chicken in a Cloud
    Handle

    Select One

    Creamy chicken and veggies nestled in a fluffy cloud of mashed potatoes, topped with melted cheese, true comfort food at it's finest! A simple and...

    Chicken in a Cloud

    Recipe #328828

    Chicken in a Cloud

    By BecR on October 5, 2008

    Recipe #328828

    Add to Cookbook Add to Menu

    "Creamy chicken and veggies nestled in a fluffy cloud of mashed potatoes, topped with melted cheese, true comfort food at it's finest! A simple and easy recipe, this casserole can be assembled in advance and popped into the oven an hour before serving. Serve with warm buttered biscuits. Enjoy! Tip: The hot mashed potatoes are especially tasty prepared..."

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: cream of chicken soup, dry mustard...

    10 Reviews

    Prep Time:15 mins

    Total Time: 1 hrs

    Recipe #275337

    Grandma Strohecker's Cider and Raisin Sauce
    Handle

    Select One

    Another recipe from the 1980 version of the Grace Evangelical Congregational Church cookbook from Muir, Pennsylvania that was given to me by my Nana when...

    Grandma Strohecker's Cider and Raisin Sauce

    By Sarah_Jayne on January 2, 2008

    Recipe #275337

    Add to Cookbook Add to Menu

    "Another recipe from the 1980 version of the Grace Evangelical Congregational Church cookbook from Muir, Pennsylvania that was given to me by my Nana when I became an adult. This recipe was submitted to the cookbook by Grandma Strohecker. As with so many of these recipes, she didn't specify serving yield. So, I am guessing a bit. I have had a version..."

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: cider, cinnamon sticks...

    1 Reviews

    Prep Time:5 mins

    Total Time: 15 mins

    Recipe #274863

    Shoo-Fly Pie
    Handle

    Select One

    Another recipe from the 1980 version of the Grace Evangelical Congregational Church cookbook from Muir, Pennsylvania that was given to me by my Nana when...

    Shoo-Fly Pie

    By Sarah_Jayne on December 30, 2007

    Recipe #274863

    Add to Cookbook Add to Menu

    "Another recipe from the 1980 version of the Grace Evangelical Congregational Church cookbook from Muir, Pennsylvania that was given to me by my Nana when I became an adult. This recipe was submitted to the cookbook by Loleda Shutt. It was one of five Sho-Fly pie recipes in the book. The real question for Sho-Fly pie lovers is - wet or dry?"

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: eggs, light brown sugar...

    Be the first to review!

    Prep Time:15 mins

    Total Time: 1 hrs 15 mins

    Old Fashioned Potato Soup
    Handle

    Select One

    Another recipe from the 1980 version of the Grace Evangelical Congregational Church cookbook from Muir, Pennsylvania that was given to me by my Nana when...

    Old Fashioned Potato Soup

    Recipe #274710

    Old Fashioned Potato Soup

    By Sarah_Jayne on December 29, 2007

    Recipe #274710

    Add to Cookbook Add to Menu

    "Another recipe from the 1980 version of the Grace Evangelical Congregational Church cookbook from Muir, Pennsylvania that was given to me by my Nana when I became an adult. This recipe was submitted to the cookbook by the Tallman Family. They run a potato processing plant in town. So, it make sense they submitted a potato recipe. As with so many..."

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: pepper, egg yolks, margarine...

    2 Reviews

    Prep Time:30 mins

    Total Time: 1 hrs 10 mins

    « Previous  123...67Next »
    Displaying up to 20 pages of results.

    Advertisement

    Newest Reviews for Amish/Mennonite Comfort Food Recipes

    Frito Lay Bean Dip

     59 Reviews

    "I think this recipe has a lot of potential. I should have re-read all of the feedback before beginning... my dip tasted tooo salty, and I generally am..." more 

    By Gidget265
    on 0

    Yummy Crunchy Caramel Apple Pie

     389 Reviews

    "My daughter made this for me for Mother's Day by my request. I have had this recipe saved in my "Want to Try" cookbook for a long time and was waiting..." more 

    By Chris from Kansas
    on 0

    Meatball Supper Soup

     13 Reviews

    "I made it pretty much as directed, except I left the bread crumbs out of the meatballs - to make them closer to a "primal or paleo" recipe. I took it to..." more 

    By thejonesgal
    on 0

    Photos

    Browse All Photos

    More Ideas from Food.com

    Cheeseburger

    Summer Central

    We've collected our best grilled recipes, pasta salads, fruit desserts and more.

    Advertisement

    Over 400,000 Recipes

    Food.com Network of Sites