I'm looking for:
  • Start Here
    • Course
    • Main Ingredient
    • Cuisine
    • Preparation
    • Occasion
    • Diet
    • Nutrition
1

Select () or exclude () categories to narrow your recipe search.

2

As you select categories, the number of matching recipes will update.

Make some selections to begin narrowing your results.
  • Calories
  • Amount per serving
    1. Total Fat
    2. Saturated Fat
    3. Polyunsat. Fat
    4. Monounsat. Fat
    5. Trans Fat
  • Cholesterol
  • Sodium
  • Potassium
  • Total Carbohydrates
    1. Dietary Fiber
    2. Sugars
  • Protein
  • Vitamin A
  • Vitamin B6
  • Vitamin B12
  • Vitamin C
  • Calcium
  • Iron
  • Vitamin E
  • Magnesium
  • Alcohol
  • Caffeine

    • Find exactly what you're looking for with the web's most powerful recipe filtering tool.

    You are in: Home / Cuisine / North American / American / Northeastern / Amish/Mennonite / Amish/Mennonite Comfort Food
    Lost? Site Map

    Amish/Mennonite Comfort Food Recipes

    Add Your Recipes

    Healthy Amish Mennonite Comfort Food Recipes

    Amish White Bread
    Handle

    Select One

    This is my favorite home baked bread recipe. I got it from an Amish cookbook years ago and no other bread recipe I have tried beats it. It is a standard...

    Amish White Bread

    Recipe #26526

    Amish White Bread

    By Karen=^..^= on April 27, 2002

    Recipe #26526

    Add to CookbookAdd to Menu

    "This is my favorite home baked bread recipe. I got it from an Amish cookbook years ago and no other bread recipe I have tried beats it. It is a standard in our house with beef stew."

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: dry yeast, salt, shortening...

    111 Reviews

    Prep Time:5 hrs

    Total Time: 5 hrs 30 mins

    Amish Potato Rolls
    Handle

    Select One

    These are so soft and yummy! They remind me of some I had as a child that a neighbor made all the time. I am so glad to have found this recipe. For...

    Amish Potato Rolls

    Recipe #178282

    Amish Potato Rolls

    By startnover on July 19, 2006

    Recipe #178282

    Add to CookbookAdd to Menu

    "These are so soft and yummy! They remind me of some I had as a child that a neighbor made all the time. I am so glad to have found this recipe. For convenience I use instant potatoes a lot and it works fine. These are even better the next day which to me with bread is rare, so I plan to make them for Thanksgiving this year."

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: eggs, warm water, salt...

    16 Reviews

    Prep Time:30 mins

    Total Time: 55 mins

    Recipe #46973

    Amish Onion Patties
    Handle

    Select One

    A nice side dish. I love thise with the sweet onions (1015, Vidalia, Maui Sweets).

    Amish Onion Patties

    By Miss Annie on November 19, 2002

    Recipe #46973

    Add to CookbookAdd to Menu

    "A nice side dish. I love thise with the sweet onions (1015, Vidalia, Maui Sweets)."

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: cornmeal, milk, onions...

    5 Reviews

    Prep Time:15 mins

    Total Time: 23 mins

    Recipe #45002

    Amish Sticky Buns, Sweet Rolls--Wow Wow Wow!
    Handle

    Select One

    These are a 'tried and true' treat here in Amish country. These will be hard to beat in flavor, and will always get rave reviews from those you...

    Amish Sticky Buns, Sweet Rolls--Wow Wow Wow!

    By WJKing on October 31, 2002

    Recipe #45002

    Add to CookbookAdd to Menu

    "These are a 'tried and true' treat here in Amish country. These will be hard to beat in flavor, and will always get rave reviews from those you choose to bless with this dish! ENJOY!"

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: cinnamon, eggs, milk...

    5 Reviews

    Prep Time:1 hrs 30 mins

    Total Time: 1 hrs 45 mins

    Recipe #102918

    Amish Noodles
    Handle

    Select One

    This is my Dad's favorite noodle recipe. He makes them for Thanksgiving and Christmas every year. Cooking time is actually the drying time. These...

    Amish Noodles

    By Mercy on October 29, 2004

    Recipe #102918

    Add to CookbookAdd to Menu

    "This is my Dad's favorite noodle recipe. He makes them for Thanksgiving and Christmas every year. Cooking time is actually the drying time. These can be frozen in zippy bags and used, as needed."

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: eggs, salt, vegetable oil...

    4 Reviews

    Prep Time:30 mins

    Total Time: 4 hrs 30 mins

    Recipe #22802

    Amish Raisin Sauce
    Handle

    Select One

    A recipe from a land where time stands still.

    Amish Raisin Sauce

    By Mille® on March 17, 2002

    Recipe #22802

    Add to CookbookAdd to Menu

    "A recipe from a land where time stands still."

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: cinnamon, cornstarch, raisins...

    2 Reviews

    Prep Time:5 mins

    Total Time: 20 mins

    Recipe #60146

    Vareniky
    Handle

    Select One

    A Russian-Mennonite dish similar to pierogies, but filled with cottage cheese, a defenite comfort food. Freezes well. This is a great vegetarian dish,...

    Vareniky

    By silly sally on April 18, 2003

    Recipe #60146

    Add to CookbookAdd to Menu

    "A Russian-Mennonite dish similar to pierogies, but filled with cottage cheese, a defenite comfort food. Freezes well. This is a great vegetarian dish, as well! They are very filling! This is one of the adopted Recipezaar recipes."

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: dry curd cottage cheese, egg whites...

    1 Reviews

    Prep Time:2 hrs

    Total Time: 2 hrs 30 mins

    Recipe #139491

    Pa Dutch Sauerkraut Dumplings
    Handle

    Select One

    Light Fluffy dumpling that looks like a snow ball. Those southern thingies are pot pie noodles any good Dutchman could tell you that. This can be used...

    Pa Dutch Sauerkraut Dumplings

    By Chef #208121 on September 29, 2005

    Recipe #139491

    Add to CookbookAdd to Menu

    "Light Fluffy dumpling that looks like a snow ball. Those southern thingies are pot pie noodles any good Dutchman could tell you that. This can be used for Sauerkraut dishes such as pork or hot dogs and sauerkraut or in our version of Chicken and dumplings, Ham and dumplings, Beef and.. you get the picture.. any meat stew."

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: eggs, milk, salt...

    1 Reviews

    Prep Time:0 mins

    Total Time: 12 mins

    Recipe #376633

    Amish Butter Noodles 1965
    Handle

    Select One

    I had these while I was having a buffet in Shipshewana, asked for the recipe for the noodles, and here it is.

    Amish Butter Noodles 1965

    By andypandy on June 10, 2009

    Recipe #376633

    Add to CookbookAdd to Menu

    "I had these while I was having a buffet in Shipshewana, asked for the recipe for the noodles, and here it is."

    View Full Recipe

    Ingredients: eggs, milk, salt...

    1 Reviews

    Prep Time:30 mins

    Total Time: 35 mins

    Advertisement

    Newest Reviews for Amish/Mennonite Comfort Food Recipes

    Frito Lay Bean Dip

     59 Reviews

    "I think this recipe has a lot of potential. I should have re-read all of the feedback before beginning... my dip tasted tooo salty, and I generally am..." more 

    By Gidget265
    on 0

    Yummy Crunchy Caramel Apple Pie

     389 Reviews

    "My daughter made this for me for Mother's Day by my request. I have had this recipe saved in my "Want to Try" cookbook for a long time and was waiting..." more 

    By Chris from Kansas
    on 0

    Meatball Supper Soup

     13 Reviews

    "I made it pretty much as directed, except I left the bread crumbs out of the meatballs - to make them closer to a "primal or paleo" recipe. I took it to..." more 

    By thejonesgal
    on 0

    Photos

    Browse All Photos

    More Ideas from Food.com

    Cheeseburger

    Summer Central

    We've collected our best grilled recipes, pasta salads, fruit desserts and more.

    Advertisement

    Over 400,000 Recipes

    Food.com Network of Sites