By Grace Lynn on August 11, 2004
Photo by Columbus Foodie
Photo by Columbus Foodie
"Wow! I just finished making this and it tastes incredible! It tastes better than the chicken makhani at my favorite Indian restaurant! You can make this as mild or spicy as you wish by adjusting the cayenne. Serve with basmati rice and naan bread. I got the recipe from allrecipes.com."
Serving Size: 1 (307 g)
Servings Per Recipe: 4
"I am re-reviewing this as I have learned some things that are worth sharing: 1) it is okay to substitute another oil for the peanut. I don't think you'll notice a big difference and it may save you some cash. Also, I turned this into a one-skillet dish and it is a little faster to cook and less mess. I added all the oil (I used shortening) at the beginning and then added the chicken after the shallot/onion mixture was translucent. I added extra garam masala and cayenne to make up for the missed chicken browning step. This yielded the same delicious dish that the two skillet method did. Also, I simmered the final product on medium low for an extra 10 or 15 minutes and it thickened up nicely and did not need cornstarch. Also, I added a half cup or so of chopped cilantro. Thanks - my husband and I LOVE this wonderful dish. Served with basmati and flat bread."
"Absolutely one of the best recipes I have tried. Taste just like the local Indian Restaurant we have in our area. It was quick and easy I didn't have ginger paste; however, I did use about a tablespoon of powdered ginger."
"I loved loved loved this! I've tried a few different recipes for Butter Chicken but this one far exceeded the others in taste and difficulty (ie much easier). I only used half a teaspoon of cayenne pepper and it was the perfect spiciness for me (I'm a bit of a wimp with really spicy stuff!)
Thank for posting this!"
"It is an awesome recipe. It came out pretty tasteful even though I was missing some ingredients. I used sour cream instead of yogurt and used heavy whipping cream in the end, and garnished with cilantro."
"I don't get how this recipe has such good reviews. This was not good at all. The yogurt curdled immediately and ruined the whole dish. The taste otherwise was nothing to write home about. Total aggravation and wasted food."
"Loved this! Wasn't quite sweet enough, so added some grated jaggery (sugar from palm sap) and adjusted it. Maybe because I used grape tomatoes that changed the recipe. Also, made my own "ginger garlic paste" and rendered the fat I cut off the thighs and cooked the chicken in that instead of peanut oil. Cooked the veggies in ghee. Mmmmm, this sauce is excellent on basmati rice."
"Great recipe! I substituted sour cream for yogurt and made my own garlic-ginger paste out of ground ginger, fresh garlic, and olive oil. And made a curry rice as a side dish. The sauce was creamy and the spice combination was perfect. Thanks!"
"My boyfriend and I made this tonight for the second time, and it turned out great. I made a few deviations from the exact recipe because I didn't have things like peanut oil or ginger-garlic paste but I, like other reviewers, also made it into a one dish recipe by browning the chicken with the onions. I didn't have cayenne pepper but I used smoked paprika instead and I think it gave the dish a great flavor.<br/>We served it over basmati rice and both of us finished this, even though it was supposed to be 4 servings."
"I enjoyed this very much (made exactly to recipe for my first try), but family not so enthusiastic. Not sure I would go through the trouble of making it again just to please myself--but I might! Prep time was longer than indicated, with a good bit of chopping."
"I am shocked at all of the positive reviews! Not only was this recipe bland, it tastes nothing like the makhani I have enjoyed at multiple Indian restaurants around the world. I purchased all of the ingredients from my local indian food store, showed the owner the recipe, and right away she was skeptical. Don't waste your time. Search for other recipes."
"This was perfect! Better than any Butter Chicken dish I've had at Indian restaurants. I would not change a thing!"
"You certainly have a winner here. Delicious! I did cut back on the cayenne, as i don't handle heat very well. :)"
"This is great! I forgot to season the chicken but it still turned out very good. My guest really loved it and made me give her the recipe before she left :) Thanks for posting!"
"I too had used only one skillet. Really no need for two. I have made other butter chickens and this is how I usually do it. I had added in the chicken after putting in the yogurt and half and half, then just simmered on low till chicken was cooked. I also had added in a lot more amount of the spices and definitely more cayenne. Also I didn't find the need for the cornstarch. Prep time is definitely more than just the 10 minutes. I had got everything measured and put into tiny condiment dishes so all I had to do was add each one, just makes things go a lot faster when making, especially when there is so many spices. For me this recipe was okay for me, but it wasn't creamy or buttery enough of a flavor compared to others I have tried. As well I just found it missing something that I couldn't quite put my finger on... It is a good recipe though and I had served it with some Naan and Potato Curry Recipe #128410 Thanks for sharing your recipe Grace"
"Made this dish last night for dinner and it was amazing! We love Indian food from our favorite restaurant, and we thought this was even better! Seemed like a lot of work when I was reading the recipe but, once I got going with it, it wasn't bad at all and I feel confident I could make this again with no problem. Definitely adding this to the repertoire! Thanks for sharing!"
"As of my first time making this, I will give it 3 stars, because I think it needs a bit of tweaking for our tastes. I was excited to find this recipe as we recently tried this in an Indian Restaurant and fell in love with it. This was a good match to what we had, however, I will cut back on the cayenne and chili powder as it was too much heat for us. Also I would like to grill or blacken the chicken to give it a more authentic flavor and I will try using fresh tomato puree hoping to get a brighter red sauce. I used canned and the color of my sauce was not as pretty as in the restaurant."
"Add me to the fans. I had to substitute half the ingredients and it still came out amazing. I used more yogurt than milk, ginger and garlic powders instead of pastes, curry leaves instead of bay leaf, ghee instead of butter. I thought it was a little too sweet for my taste so I added lemon powder and more salt. I also went heavy on the spices and flavorings b/c I like food that goes KaPow! Garnish with cilantro and sliced lemon, serve with okra. Heaven!"
"WOW WOW WOW. Friggin amazing! I realized at the last minute that I didn't have tomato puree, so I used a half a small can of tomato paste and a cup of water. I also didn't have the yogurt.
Made with homeade naan....this was SO GOOD!"
"I made this with tofu by cooking cubed tofu with the onions and proceeding with the recipe up until the chicken part. It tasted completely different from what I expected, but was very, very good! I think it'd actually be great on pasta and veggies."