By Connie K on April 09, 2004
Photo by Kathy228
Photo by Kathy228
"Great vegetarian comfort food! Don't be fooled by the ingredients; the flavor is very much like meatloaf. Kitchen alchemy at its finest!"
Serving Size: 1 (121 g)
Servings Per Recipe: 8
"First of all let me say that I AM NOT a vegetarian. But this is a really great tasting vegetarian loaf!! I did make quite a few substitutions due to other reviews and am listing as someone might find something useful. For the cup of walnuts I used 1/4 cup of walnuts finely chopped, about 1/3 cup of ground flax seed and finished the cup with wheat bran. I didn't have any Special K and used ground, high protein, whole wheat bread crumbs (2 cups). For extra flavor I added ketchup (about 1/3 cup), worchestershire sauce (1- 2 Tablespoons), garlic, parsley, salt and chervil. Did not use any of the vegetable oil as there is enough oil in the walnuts and ground flax seed. No need to add extra fat and calories. The eggs hold this loaf together wonderfully. Baked in mini loaf pans for about 40 minutes and topped with more ketchup. Absolutely outstanding flavor, moist and just as good if not better than any meat loaf I've ever made! You can be sure I'll be making this again and again. I served this with steamed asparagus and cheesy mashed potatoes. Thanks so much for posting Connie."
"In short: this meatloaf is AMAZING. Go make it now. Stop reading reviews, don't even bother to get out of your pjs, just leave the house and run to the store now to make this.
This will now be a permanent part of our frequent dinners rotation. To die for delicious vegetarian meatloaf. Tastes just like the meatloaf I remember from childhood, but without that meaty-gross aftertaste. WOW. THANK YOU FOR THIS!!!!!"
"like everyone has said, it's an impressive approximation of meatloaf.
and yes, it all seems an odd fit and you don't think it looks right when you put it in the oven, but it is!
if you're making your own spice mix, 1oz = 2T, though keep in mind 2T of say, cayenne, will not be pleasant.
i'm not really a fan of the medley texture, so really mincing the nuts to keep the different textures down, helps me."
"I was looking for a way to use up cottage cheese and stumbled on to this recipe. I had never heard of this before but all the ingredients were things we like and the photo by Kathy228 was so impressive that I thought I'd give it a try and am glad I did. I hate reviews were people change every ingredient but after I started making this I discovered I had no corn flakes so I had to substitute Stove Top dressing mix and I'm so glad I did. It really added a good flavor. Other than that I wouldn't change a thing. I loved the nuts in the meatloaf. This smelled heavenly while cooking. I didn't tell my family it wasn't meatloaf and no one knew. Amazing! Thanks so much for posting."
"This was great!! Instead of the oil I added 6 TB of flax seed. I used 1 1/2 cups of bran flakes and 1/2 cup of oatmeal. And fat free cottage cheese. I used the sauce from recipe http://www.food.com/recipe/meatloaf-yes-virginia-there-is-a-great-meatloaf-54257 to put on the top. I made sure that the pan was well greased."
"I'm quite impressed with this recipe. I only made one ingredient change, which was adding dried onions instead of fresh. This is easy to make and all 3 of my kiddos love it. DH is very much a carnivore and even proclaimed it 'ok'. Instead of making this in a loaf pan I portioned it out into muffin cups. I froze the leftovers but I haven't tried the frozen portions yet (I'll post on the outcome of this once I try it). The frozen portions are all gone and they were as wonderful as the just-baked. Thanks so much for this recipe!!!"
"OK, how funny is this stuff?!?!? Love that it tastes great and that it stays together (not crumbly like many other "veggie loaves"). I used sunflower seeds in place of the walnuts, added a handful of grated carrots (totally melted in and were undetectable), and instead of oil I added some Heinz 57 sauce. Mine was a tad bit salty, so next time I will not use Heinz 57 sauce, but use some unsalted tomato sauce. We topped ours off with some mushroom gravy. . .yummo!"
"Just amazing! I've been searching for a meatless recipe that tastes like actual meatloaf and this definetly fits the bill. I only made a few very small modifications- instead of walnuts I used almonds and I didn't use any chopped onions. This will be made again. I can't to use the leftovers on sandwiches tomorrow. Update: I made this 2x in one week- that's how great it it... Leftovers are excellent, and I love using the leftovers on hamburger buns with pickle and mustard- it kind of reminds me of "sliders". I have made this with and without nuts, and both are great!"
"I was very eager to try out this recipe, and wanted so badly to like it. I made it as written, but could not eat it. Let me just say that the consistency was pretty accurate, though obviously true meatloaf will be firmer. The flavor was entirely lacking, with the exception of a ketchup-based glaze I made on the top. If I were ever to take another crack at this recipe, here is what I would do: 1) follow another poster's suggestion to use Stove Top stuffing in lieu of the corn flakes 2) add more finely chopped onion and put in chopped bell pepper as well and 3) make sure those walnuts are ground to oblivion. Hope this is helpful, as it is intended to be!"
"I've also used pecans and that is good too."
"I've made this several times now since it is so good. To keep it from being too salty, I just use half a package of seasoning (onion soup, taco seasoning or meatloaf mix.) I then boost up the flavor with extra fresh onions or dehydrated vegetables. I've also made this with all Italian seasonings, including fennel seeds. Delicious."
"Well I must admit I was pretty skeptical, even more so when I saw the big mess of stuff in the bowl. But I had come this far so I decided to cook it up. Well...I am currently eating this and I must say I like it! It has a nice texture and pleasing taste. I added a couple of finely chopped sauted mushrooms to mine....<br/>Smelled really good while cooking and looks just like regular meatloaf other than the curds of cottage cheese which somehow maintained their shape. (I think I used large curd). Regardless, tastes good and I give it 5 stars."
"So delicious! Made recipe as directed with some flax seed added, very yum. Next time I will use less onion soup mix, was a bit too salty for me. Another review was dead on when they said that it does not look like much when you put it in oven, but when you take it out, it looks like old fashioned meatloaf! Used my leftovers in wheat pita pocket with spinach, that was even delicious. Will be making this again and again!"
"Husband & I Vegetarian since 1989. Have made many a loaf/roast. This one is a wonderful find. Easy, fast and unbelievably good. Great consistency, texture and taste. Only changes I made: subbed dried onion for fresh and a packet of dry ranch dressing for dry onion soup mix - what I had in pantry. Baked in convection oven for full 70 minutes. Will reduce 15 minutes next time. Will make this frequently, varying the seasoning and add-ins."
"This was absolutely amazing! Being a vegetarian in the south, it is incredibly difficult to find home-like comfort food and this is by far the best recipe I have found to match that description. I followed the recipe exactly, using two cups of store brand corn flakes. I also used low fat cottage cheese. I was amazed with how good this was and how closely it resembled real meat loaf. I will definitely be making this again!"
"Wow I really loved this "meatloaf." It only has a vague meaty flavor, but I don't really like vegetarian food that tastes like meat anyway I ended up using bran flakes instead of corn flakes, and left out the onion, but otherwise followed the recipe exactly. Very tasty- I will be making this often :)"
"good texture but very bland."
"Loved, loved, loved it! Followed recipe exactly. We served it with mashed potatoes, corn and barbecue sauce. My young kids only ate a few bites but my husband had three servings. This is a keeper for me."
"I just couldn't believe how these simple ingredients make such a great meal! My husband's a vego but I'm not so we're always trying to make dinners to satisfy both our palettes and this did! Delicious and filling :)"
"I have to admit, no one was very excited when they saw what was for dinner. We were all pleasantly surprised. DH is a meat and potatoes guy and he had seconds! I used low fat cottage cheese, corn flakes, and egg beaters. I baked it for 60 minutes. Next time I might leave it in an extra 5 minutes, but wouldn't make any other changes. Thanks for a great meal."