By ~*Miss Diggy*~ on October 06, 2003
Photo by Chef #594755
Photo by Chef #594755
"These are wonderful cookies for the fall."
Serving Size: 1 (1327 g)
Servings Per Recipe: 1
"Soft, moist cookie full of flavor. Due to some allergies in our house, we had to modify the recipe by using raisins instead of chocolate chips and 1/4 cup applesauce instead of the egg. Otherwise, delish!"
"YUM!! I made these this afternoon and they were delicious! I did make a few changes (as I usually do to make healthier changes) I used all whole wheat flour, replaced the egg with flax, only used 1/2 cup butter and replaced the other 1/2 with pumpkin puree and cut the sugar in half. I also added another cup of oatmeal because the batter seemed a bit thin....but other than that...I guess that's alot of changes isn't it? that is all I did. Will definitely be making these again! I think they will be great for school lunches in the fall!! And pretty healthy, too! And of course I love anything pumpkin! I also forgot, I baked them in a 375 degree convection oven for 10 minutes and they came out perfectly!!"
"Very good.. I added walnuts to some of them in addition to the chocolate & cinnamon chips and they were delicious as well."
"Fixed these for a delayed Halloween party -- stayed strictly to the recipe, oven temp, and time -- turned out perfectly ! I had TRIED to find the sugar discs shaped like pumpkins to put on top -- none to be found ! had a 4-part canister with orange and black shake toppings and sugar crystals, which added a festive touch. Got 57 cookies with #40 Zeroll scoop. I guess they were good -- they were GONE ! Thanks for posting, ~*Miss Diggy*~."
"These cookies are great. I love the addition of th cinnamon chips. Thanks for sharing!"
"OMG these cookies were delish! Everyone from my 3 yo to my grandmother loved these cookies. The texture was perfect (even the few I hid for myself stayed fresh and soft for a few days!) I did add extra cinnamon and nutmeg. YUM YUM YUM, making these again and again for the fall/winter season. I have found my new cookie tray addition!"
"I"ve made these a few times, but have yet to rate them. YUM! I subbed 1 cup of whole wheat pastry flour for white, used butterscotch, white and semi-sweet chocolate chips. I aslo threw in a dash of pumpkin pie spice. Mine were perfectly soft after cooking for 15 minutes. Next time, I'll try subbing out some of the butter with applesauce. Some chopped pecans might be a nice addition as well. Thanks for a great fall cookie recipe!"
"These were good, but just didn't satisfy my sweet tooth!! They would be great as a breakfast cookie. The only thing I did differently was to replace the oil with applesauce. They were very soft and chewy. Thanks for posting!!"
"Made as written except I swapped out butterscotch chips for chocolate (did not use the cinnamon) as it was what I had on hand. Worked perfect flavor-wise & I'll stick with those for the future. Great cookie - just a little crunchy around the edges but moist & almost a little bit cake like in the middle. Very light, not overpowering & a big hit with everyone. Mine were perfectly done at 17 minutes & I got 4 1/2 dozen out of this recipe. Def. let them cool on the sheet for 2-3 minutes before transfering to a cooling rack or they will crumble. Thanks for sharing!"
"I made the usual substitutions for this, 1 cup of wheat flour for 1 of the cups of white flour, applesauce for the butter, egg substitute for the egg and left out the chips. I also threw in a banana, trying to get everything I can in! These were outstanding and my 3 year "taste tested" 3 of them in less than 2 minutes no joke. I had no problems with transferring them off the cookie sheet once they had cooled slightly and these were incredibly moist so no crumbling whatsoever. Excellent recipe, very happy with the results will most definitely be making these again, THANKS!"
"These cookies tasted very good. I used whole wheat flour and didn't use the cinnamon baking chips as we didn't have any. 13 minutes cooking time was long enough for each cookie sheet. They just didn't come off the pan like I would like them to. Then I made the mistake of stacking them to make more room and later found them to fall apart as I put them in a container. I may have been from the whole wheat flour, but I always use it and this has never happened. Great taste, just frustrated with them falling apart."
"I planted pie pumpkins for the first time this year because I do not like the taste of "canned" pumpkin, the plant yielded 15 pumpkins so I needed pumpkin recipes. I made these 2 weeks ago, FAB-U-LOUS! Soft, favorful, easy. Everyone I gave them to wanted the recipe...This IS the Great Pumpkin Cookie, Charlie Brown!"
"YUM!! I had some leftover pumpkin to use up and the kids wanted cookies, so I decided to give this recipe a try. Didn't have any chocolate or cinnamon chips, but I'm sure that only would have made these taste better! I was a little surprised by how wet the dough seemed, but they baked up perfectly! Very soft and cake-like in texture. Great cookie!!"
"Wonderful!!! Even my picky 4-yr old twins loved these cookies. I used both cinnamon & semi-sweet chips & they were great. Thanks so much!! "
"These were fantastic! I made them for my daughter's Halloween party at school, and they were a big hit. I wasn't sure about the combination of pumpkin and chocolate, but I am sold now! I did use mini-morsels instead of regular chocolate chips, so the flavor wasn't as overwhelming. I will be making these again and again!"
"I liked these cookies' flavour a lot, though I must say they weren't enough "pumpkiny" for me...perhaps next time I'll add a bit more spices and I'll try substituting part of the butter with some more pumpkin puree...We don't have cinnamon chips here in Italy, and I'm sure they would've made the difference; I made three batches, one with just chocolate chips, one with choc chips and chopped walnuts, and one omitting the choc chips and using instead raisins and chopped walnuts, most people said they prefer this last version. Thank you for a lovely fall recipe that lends itself to many interpretations, I'll definitely keep it as a "base" and play around with different ingredients, which is the best thing in cooking for me!"
"These are very good cookies!! Made them last night to take to some friends as they work to open their new grocery store. Nice and soft-added a few more chocolate chips, but not the cinnamon ones, just because I forgot to buy them!! Will definitely make again!Thanks for sharing! "
"Yummy cookies! I went on my merry way making these and when I got to the end of step 3(adding the dry ingredients) I clued in that the pumpkin hadn't been added yet!(missing from the directions) Obviously it should have gone in with the wet stuff!Anyhow I ended up mixing it in after the dry stuff and things were still fine in the end! I made most of them with just chocolate chips and decided to add the cinnamon chips to the last batch. My sister stopped by while I was making them and we both thought they were better with the cinnamon chips added! Mine seemed to be ready in about 13 mins. and they were just as I like them nice & soft & chewey. Still soft the next day too! They didn't last long! Thanks for a yummy cookie! "
"This is a great recipe. Very easy to make. I brought them back to school with me and the guys loved them!"
"Hey Diggy, this is a delicious cookie recipe! My whole family loved them. I did add a little more chocolate chips. I could not get the cinnamon chips. Moist and chewy! Thanks Diggy"